Saturday, February 09, 2013

BIRTH STORY



The Day You Came

Wanda Ruby Bean

From a distance the sound of familiar footsteps enter, softly resonating the hallway boards. That long cool passage welcomes and grounds the energy of arrival, and those footsteps always speak to me of strength, confidence and calmness. They are slow, they are regular, and they belong, each time they place themselves down, yet there is a lightness to them that contains their energy, allowing them to change their course. These are the footsteps of my father. They are the rhythm.

There is a second set of footsteps proceeding, which skate and dance on the surface. They have the same base confidence whilst infusing a melody of willingness, playfulness and excitement, the footsteps of my mother.

As the footsteps reach the end of the passage, time and space briefly pause. The early afternoon sun has just begun to creep through the wooden blinds and open door, filling the room with the blissful warmth and breeze of a perfect day. From over backyard fences and beyond, a relaxed inhabited neighbourhood enters the room, joining us in building the sense of this gathering and impending celebration.

We are all here now, and it is soon to be that you will join us.

Joy is here – she kneels by the pool quietly guiding me to allow you to work your way down, and to allow my body to open by degrees until your head can come through. She squeezes a cramp from my thigh. I bury my face into the crook of her arm. Our eyes meet and I tell her ‘I’m glad you’re here’.
She gives me the practical confidence at this stage that I need to enjoy this moment and to trust the forces and the will of my body and yours.

Hamish is here – he has been on the edges, balancing between active support and giving me space. He has prepared the room in the final hours to absolute, in timing, function and style, invited the guests, thought about lunch, and even got the bins out in time for collection. And as only Hamish could, has peppered his day with a set of slightly mad but comical dramas.
He is beside me at the pools edge. He even offers up his flesh for my bite, a running joke we have had. I appreciate it but decline, briefly gnawing on the pool instead. He holds me, and I tell him ‘Beano is coming’. We exchange a look of excitement and bemusement, the humour we share about this realisation that has never yet really sunk in. I don’t need physical or emotional support from him, I need to include him in this moment and feel the union that we are in order to bring you into our world together.

Mum is here – she peeps shyly over to me holding a face and breath of thrill, anticipation and quietness. The same energy I recognise at times that I have been witness to an animal birthing. ‘Hello’ and my wide eyes greet her in smile. I am relieved she has made it in time, and relieved that this is the moment she has arrived. Before long she slips easily under Joys instruction to prepare warm towels and other things in preparation, as you are nearly here. The combination of gentle mothering and practical assistant is the perfect and natural balance of how I had wanted to share this journey of womanhood with her.
Dad is here – a welcome addition to the arrangements. He primarily came to deliver mum and take Velouer out for a walk. As it turned out Velouer is completely calm. It is so close to the time you will arrive th0at he stays quietly in the background. I am happy he is here, and want to tell him. Under my breath I invite him to stay. I don’t think anyone hears me but the atmosphere as it is, is enough for him to feel welcome and comfortable to stay. I feel an extra sense of love and significance that he does.

Velouer is here – my beautiful loyal dog. He has been with me throughout. In the early hours of the day he lay beside me, calmly and comfortably as I worked physically and vocally with the surges in my body. It had been thought by others that he would be distressed by the energy of my birthing. I knew that he would be fine, and I had wanted him here. We are part of each other and we understand on an instinctual level. He gives me comfort by just being, eyes to talk to, and an energy of calm. He gives me space but is there, there to protect me as people arrive, and there to accept and welcome the people as he knows them. He takes his place as he always does amongst the people and space in the room. I tell him ‘good boy’.

I am here – I have always been here with you, and until now had you all to myself… although you have kept yourself well as a little mystery, a quiet enigma.
In the hours of this day I have re-found the essential core connection to my body, brought my mind in and allowed and trusted the forces, the choices and the beings that surround me now.
Just one little wild card is you. As my body works in the final stages to release and expel you I embody a physical memory of a young goat birthing her first kid. She lays in the hay calmly allowing the process, as the head finally pops out beyond return, a brief flash of shock and then realisation of what this labour is all for comes across her face. Then the long glorious quiver as your body swims from me and comes up to land in the air, our bodies skin to skin.

You have arrived – a tiny little stranger person. Taking your first breaths with sleepy eyes blinking quietly, with little wrinkled hands you gently play and clutch at the air. You take a shy little peek up to me. I hold you to my belly and paddle the warm water over your body with my hand, letting us the time to readjust and take it in.

Everyone is having their own special moments with you around us. Like a conglomerate of prismatic bubbles floating gently in the earthly sun filled room.

Wanda Ruby Bean - we love you to pieces already.

Frances Martin

Saturday, February 02, 2013

I wonder if he reflected on what he said?


Today I want to look at the words of an obstetrician who was interviewed for an ABC TV story 'Call for wider availability of home birthing' on the 7:30 report last night.


The professional body representing obstetricians, RANZCOG, strenuously opposes homebirth, and appears to have no interest in opening pathways for midwives to have visiting access for clinical privileges in hospitals - public or private.  The midwife's place is working in hierarchical maternity care models in hospitals.  The obstetric dominated maternity care has no place for the sort of midwifery that I have practised for the past 2 decades: private midwifery practice in which I have a small caseload of 2-4 births per month.  Most of the mothers in my care are planning homebirth.  Others are planning to give birth at the hospital, and I become the primary carer working within a larger team, and a sort of 'event manager' during the hospital stay.

Back to the 7:30 report.

Two obstetricians were interviewed.  Euan Wallace is director of obstetrics at Southern Health, the large network that covers Monash Medical Centre, as well as Casey, Dandenong, and Sandringham hospital maternity units.  Dr Wallace spoke of the (publicly funded) homebirth program within Southern Health as "one of the jewels" in the program.  He compared the relative rarity of homebirth in Australia, less than 0.5% of all births, with the UK: that in Australia homebirth seems to have a "wackyness" about it!   His heavy Scots accent suggests that his life experience is less insular than many of his obstetric colleagues.  He called homebirth an appropriate choice for certain women, and a choice that women should have, wherever they live in Victoria.

The other obstetrician, Michael Permezel, spoke on behalf of RANZCOG.  It is his comments that have left me wondering if he has reflected on what he said.  In short, he said women can't be given the responsibility to make a choice about homebirth.

Patronising? Definitely. 

RANZCOG does not support homebirth because, he said, there are a few nasty things that can happen at home that would be better managed in hospital.  By some amazing stroke of [un-]logic, it follows that if homebirth was offered, women would get a false message about the safety of homebirth.  That it would somehow give out a wrong message, leading women to imagine that availability of the program implied safety.  [This is not a verbatum quote, but it's very close.]

Readers of this blog are probably mostly people who have heard all this before, and who do not think that women who choose homebirth are deluded or intellectually impaired.

In a brief response to the RANZCOG position as stated by Prof Permezel, I acknowledge that there are occasions when unpredictable events can quickly escalate into the need for emergency obstetric or neonatal medical treatment.  This is not a homebirth issue: it's a life issue.   It's something that maternity hospitals face every night when their operating theatre staff go home.  Even the big tertiary centres face the possibility of doctors and midwives being unskilled when a woman presents in spontaneous labour with a breech baby.


Women who sit down in my office to discuss homebirth are not ignorant; are not holding onto false notions about the safety of homebirth.  They are usually very well informed, and are making plans that give them the best options that are available to them.  These women, and I, the midwife, are deeply offended by the suggestion of this obstetrician that they somehow don't have the capacity to weigh the risks against the benefits of different options.

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

"I'm glad you're here."

The young woman was labouring hard when I arrived.  Hers was a better-than-textbook first labour: she got up at 4:30 am; was having mild contractions every 7 or 8 minutes by breakfast time; accelerated into 3 contractions every 10 minutes by mid-morning; and felt like pushing before midday.  After quickly arranging my few pieces of equipment I knelt beside the birth pool, checked the fetal heart rate after a contraction, and waited with her.  When her eyes met mine, she whispered, "I'm glad you're here."

The home, a lovely old inner-suburban Melbourne cottage, seemed to embrace and welcome this birth.  There was harmony and warmth in the exposed brick walls.  The baltic pine floor boards showed the wear of many occupants over the years. The mild summer day, and a gentle breeze, gave support and energy to the work of childbirth.  I learned later that the young woman's parents had lived in this home when their first child was born, and that several of the babies of this family had either been conceived there, or were brought there after birth. 

"I'm glad you're here."

The mechanisms of birth proceeded without delay.  The strong, expulsive effort of the womb, brought the little head to the vaginal opening.  We had no mirrors or torches - we worked by feel rather than by sight.  The mother's hand gave her all the information she needed.  After the head had fully emerged we waited, then supported the baby as she came to the surface of the water, opened her lungs, and took her first breaths of air.  After a brief rest we assisted the mother and her baby out of the pool, and they rested as we awaited the after-birth.  There was no bleeding.  There was no cause for concern at any time.

I reflected on that simple statement, "I'm glad you're here", as I completed the day's work, writing my notes and preparing the official birth documentation.  I reflected on them again as I visited the home the next day.

"I'm glad you're here" was firstly a statement of the rightness of home as the setting for this birth.  The young mother told me later that she would have found it very difficult to know when to travel, if she had been required to go to hospital.

It was also a statement of the rightness of the 'with woman' relationship.  The partnership I have with that young woman is a unique and special bond.

Clearly, this birth did not rely on any special skill or treatment that I might have offered.  Apart from putting my hand gently on the woman's leg when she felt a muscle cramp, I did very little.  A new graduate midwife could have done everything that I did.  The midwife attending a home birth relies more on the wonderful spontaneous actions of the woman's body, than on any midwifery act.  The essence of midwifery is being, rather than doing.

"I'm glad you're here" says it all.




Monday, January 28, 2013

midwife-centred language

We midwives have theories about woman-centred care.  The woman and her baby are the focus, and their individual needs guide the planning and providing of maternity care.  The provision of basic primary maternity care through the months of the pregnancy, birth, and neonatal period from a known midwife facilitates, in theory at least, the development of a unique partnership between the woman and her midwife, and supporting woman-centred care.

Many times, in reality, 'woman-centred care' is a hollow and meaningless phrase.   Aspects of the care are dictated by the service providing maternity care, limited by staff numbers and funding arrangements, and fragmented into 'items' that can be entered as numbers into databases.

My attention was piqued the other day when a midwife in a hospital used the word 'passive' in relation to the third stage.  The mother who was about to give birth spontaneously, without medication, had indicated that she did not want synthetic oxytocin to be injected into her after the birth.  The midwife, correctly, informed the woman that the hospital's policy required her to perform active management of the third stage.  The woman replied "No, thankyou."  The midwife then referred to what proceeded as 'passive management'.

  • ... passive [management], as opposed to active management

Before you nod your head and say, "OK, passive means not administering the oxytocic, not applying cord traction, not checking the fundus for evidence of separation of the placenta (and whatever else, such as cord clamping, is considered part of active management)", let me explain what is wrong with the concept of 'passive' third stage.

  • midwife-centred language
Active management, or passive [non-]management are terms that refer to the midwife's actions.  The woman is virtually invisible.  This is not woman-centred care.

  • ignorance
I witness appalling ignorance within the mainstream midwifery and obstetric community with regard to the uninterrupted physiological processes that lead to safe and optimal completion of the third stage of labour.  The 'broad brush' approach, treat everyone, regardless of the need, as required by the hospital's policy, leads to the deskilling of midwives who ought to be competent in protecting and supporting the physiological processes in childbirth.  This is also not woman-centred care.

  • denial of a woman's ability to make an informed decision
A woman who is progressing spontaneously in birth, and who indicates that she prefers a spontaneous and unmedicated third stage, can easily be denied the opportunity to proceed when the midwife uses the 'hospital policy' card. 


What is a physiological third stage?
Put simply, a physiological third stage is the spontaneous and unmedicated completion of the birthing process, after the birth of the baby (second stage), resulting in the expulsion of the placenta and membranes.

The Women's Hospital guidelines* defines physiological management of third stage as:
Physiological management: The birth of the placenta and membranes are expelled by maternal effort only and without using uterotonic agents or controlled cord traction.
[note the midwife-centred language: turning the focus from the woman, whose body is achieving a significant and healthy function, to the midwife.]

This is a totally inadequate definition, and is evidence of my previous assertion that midwives and obstetricians have become de-skilled in supporting physiological processes in birth.

I have described aspects of physiological third stages in recent posts, for example:

... The cord was not clamped.  We supported the mother as she stepped out of the birth pool, holding her treasure to her chest, dried them off, and sat them quietly in the prepared chair.  As contractions returned, the mother stood, then squatted over a plastic bowl, all the time holding her naked baby against her naked body, and the placenta was expelled spontaneously.  Blood loss was minimal.  [from The After-Glow]

 and
... A healthy baby made his grand entrance, and no drugs were used.  The woman birthed her placenta spontaneously about 30 minutes after the birth, with minimal blood loss. [from Hospital policy in the spotlight]

What is the midwife's role in physiological third stage?

Having accepted that a woman who gives birth spontaneously and unmedicated, and who is intentional about continuing in the natural physilogical mode unless there is "a valid reason to interfere with the natural process" (WHO 1996. Care in Normal Birth: a practical guide),  the midwife's role is (obviously) to support and protect that natural process.

In the two birth accounts that I have referred to above, the midwife's role included assisting the mother into a supported position, such as sitting upright on a chair, with warm, dry wraps around herself and her baby.  The midwife manages the environment, rather than the labour, encouraging the mother to focus exclusively on her baby who rests quietly in her arms before seeking the breast.  The midwife ensures any activity around the mother is kept to a minimum.  If photos are being taken, this is done in an unobtrusive way.  The midwife notices signs of separation of the placenta, and instructs the baby's father on how to support the mother as she stands or squats over a bowl to expel the placenta, if she needs to.

There is nothing at all passive about the midwife's role in supporting and protecting the natural physiological processes in birth. 

I need to sign off now, as a mother is in labour and I expect to be called soon to attend.

The message of this post is that when we, the midwives, focus on the woman, we are able to work with her.  Our language reveals the focus of our care: either the woman, or ourselves.


*Active Management: go to the Women's Hospital guidelines and click on 'Labour-Third Stage Management'


Saturday, January 26, 2013

celebrating 40 years

yes, we were young and beautiful!

Thursday, January 17, 2013

the after-glow

Picture the scene:

We are in the room where the baby was born, just over 24 hours earlier.
The mother is sitting quietly, with a sleeping baby in her arms.
The father is near her, and other children come and go - as they do.
The midwife and the midwifery student have returned for a postnatal visit, and as there is no pressing clinical activity to attend to, we are simply 'being' rather than 'doing'.

Gone is the inflated birth pool, the tarp that covered the carpet, and the protective drape and old beach towels that covered the chair where the mother waited for her placenta to birth.

Gone are the candles and other soft lights that provided a warm and intimate glow as we welcomed this little one into her family.

Gone are the simple midwifery tools: the absorbent 'blueys', the box of blue gloves, the doppler, the oxygen bottle, and other resuscitation gear, the syringe and needle and oxytocic to be used if required ...


The daylight of this summer morning enters the room through the large window. 

Another light, which I call 'the after-glow', rests on the faces of all who are present.


There was no camera to document the after-glow, and indeed, if someone had tried to capture that moment, I doubt the memory would have nestled so strongly in my heart, or urged me to write it down.   In many ways, it was an unremarkable moment.

Yet, the discussion that followed was full of awe and wonder.  The miracle of birth, by which a child is safely brought from the womb to the arms of the mother, never ceases to offer insight to anyone who has eyes to see and ears to hear.  The natural physiological process, spontaneous yet so very vulnerable to any interruption or interference, is somehow unnoticed by our society and particularly mainstream maternity services.

If I have learnt anything in these past 20 or so years of private midwifery practice, working closely with a few women, most of whom intend to give birth without medical intervention, it's that there is so much more to learn.

As we reviewed the experiences and events of this labour and birth, we were reminded that this mother would have been treated as 'at risk' if she had been in hospital.  A previous caesarean requires, in most maternity hospitals, continuous electronic fetal monitoring throughout active labour.  Parity greater than 5, as well as the caesarean scar, require an intravenous cannula to be in situ.  Active management of the third stage is the standard process in local hospitals for all women. 

Yet this birth proceeded spontaneously at home, without incident or complication.  The mother guided her baby's head over her perineum, without any instruction to 'pant' or 'give a push now'.  The baby came up out of the water, took air into her lungs, and made that great transition from placental oxygen to the bountiful air without any difficulty.  The cord was not clamped.  We supported the mother as she stepped out of the birth pool, holding her treasure to her chest, dried them off, and sat them quietly in the prepared chair.  As contractions returned, the mother stood, then squatted over a plastic bowl, all the time holding her naked baby against her naked body, and the placenta was expelled spontaneously.  Blood loss was minimal.  Baby took the breast eagerly - as they do.  After an hour or so the father took his daughter, and the mother achieved her next milestone, that of emptying her bladder.

Anyone reading this might ask, what's so special about that? 

It's the simplicity of uncomplicated, unassisted birth that I want to record here.  Simple, yet amazingly complex in the orchestration of hormones and the mechanics of the process.  Spontaneous, yet vulnerable to interruption or disruption.

Midwives must work to protect, promote and support birth in the natural framework that has been provided by our Creator, unless there is a valid reason to avoid the spontaneous normal process.

Sunday, January 13, 2013

how to promote midwifery?

I have often pondered this question, how to promote midwifery. 

Although midwifery is my livelihood, promotion of midwifery goes way beyond making a living and paying the bills.

Today I have drafted this sign, through which I hope to promote midwifery.  Although this sign has my contact phone number, my intention is to provide this as a template for other Medicare-participating midwives.

I have used colours and fonts that are consistent with the official Medicare signage and posters.  (unfortunately the quality of my printer's colours atm is not very good)  The colours and font should elicit a recognition response from the general community.  The fact that a midwife can offer Medicare rebates will be 'NEWS' to many in the community.

The key message is: "protecting the wellbeing of mother and child".  This is foundational to midwifery, and to the provision of expert primary maternity services in communities.


Another new initiative on my part is to start up a facebook group, which I have named 'villagemidwife'.  I do not particularly enjoy facebook, and its reliance on thumbs up 'like' votes about anything that is posted.  However, I am conscious that facebook is the social medium used by many young women of childbearing age, and therefore important.

For the record, other facebook professional groups that I belong to are:
breech birth ANZ
eligible midwives
graduate certificate of midwifery at Flinders
Australian College of Midwives


Thankyou for your comments.

Friday, January 04, 2013

Looking ahead: midwife-led primary maternity care

Today is a hot day in Melbourne, and I am taking this moment to set down my thoughts on how I and other midwives can continue to practise our profession.

Prior to the holiday break I wrote a progress report, two years after the introduction of reforms to government funding of maternity care.

There was clearly an expectation within the government, and the midwifery profession and the maternity advocacy community that the injection of $$ to fund midwifery would also open up greater acceptance of the work of the midwife.   It was assumed that private midwifery would ease the work of the over-burdened hospital system, public and private.  I cannot see evidence of this.  In fact, the money from the public purse has probably increased over-servicing by multiple service providers, rather than any cost shifting from the state (hospital) to the federal (Medicare) health budgets.

 


IDEALS AND REALITIES
The unique product that midwife-led primary maternity care offers a woman is a midwife who is the primary or first contact throughout the episode of care.  This is, in my opinion, the ideal option for any woman, and the ideal model in which a midwife can practise.  This ideal requires the midwife to be flexible in the time she will attend the mother, particularly during the labour, birth, and the early postnatal days.  The midwife's caseload is usually described by the number of bookings she has each month.  This ideal is supported by expert opinion and research, in the interests of the wellbeing and safety of mother and baby. 

Caseloads for midwives mean that the mother is in the care of a known midwife who intends to be the leading care professional through pregnancy, birth, and the postnatal period, unless care is referred to a specialist obstetrician (or hospital obstetric service).  In this case, the midwife may continue to provide midwifery care, in consultation/cooperation with others (doctors, midwives, nurses, and other health services as required).

In reality, this ideal is rarely achieved.  This ideal should not be linked to planned place of birth, but in reality it is.  The only way most women can plan to have a known midwife as their primary carer throughout the episode of care is to plan homebirth. 

In reality, Australian hospitals and midwives are resistent to the changes that would be needed to make caseload midwifery options work for midwives in mainstream maternity services.  Women receive fragmented care that comes with all sorts of names attached: shared antenatal care, team care, obstetric clinic, midwives clinic, and many more.  Maternity wards and staff are used to midwives as shift workers, who are allocated to provide care for the women in the ward at the beginning of a shift.  The mother receives antenatal, perinatal and postnatal care from a group of midwives, doctors, and others, without knowing who will attend her at any time.


LOOKING AHEAD:
The maternity 'reforms' seem to be fragmenting the maternity care a midwife can provide, under a skewed concept called collaboration.

 
Midwives don't always agree on the way forward.
One midwife might be a pragmatist, and make an arrangement with the hospital maternity ward that she will be employed as a casual staff member when her clients are ready to be admitted. 

Another midwife is holding out, and hoping, for visiting access to the hospital.

One midwife might be an idealist, who will only make bookings to provide care for women who are committed to home birth. 

Another midwife is not interested in where the woman is intending to give birth ...

I have come to this latter position.  I recognise and respect the choice that a woman has to make, in the world in which we live, as to the intended place of birth.  I also know that this decision can change in a flash, for all sorts of reasons.  There are times when a woman who plans hospital birth reconsiders her options, perhaps in the weeks leading up to birth.  I am happy to work through this process.

One change that I and some of my colleagues have made, in response to the current climate of disrespect for the work of the private midwife, is to encourage women who intend to give birth in hospital to make a deliberate choice about the package of care they receive.  A woman can choose to receive primary care from a midwife, without having to plan home birth.  In some situations the hospital accepts a booking, but in others the woman will be unbooked.  This should not be a problem.   The administrative burden on the hospital of admitting an unbooked woman, especially in well staffed city and suburban hospitals, is not great.  The private midwife provides copies of any relevant tests and investigations, and a handover to the staff member who admits the woman.


Some midwives who have had Medicare provider numbers since 2010 have not yet established viable private midwifery practices.  They continue to juggle shift work in part-time or casual work at hospitals, while they seek private work.  Women are being discharged from public and private hospitals before they are confident in caring for themselves or their babies.  Many of these women would, I believe, appreciate home visits from a private midwife who has Medicare.  This is not happening.  The hospitals do not refer women to midwives.  They are happy to say "See your GP if you have a problem", but not "See your local private midwife before problems arise."


In conclusion, we still have a lot of work to do.

Sunday, December 23, 2012

Christmas greetings

Thanks to Bec for the pic.
Loving greetings
from our home to yours
“Let us now go to Bethlehem, and see this thing that has taken place, which the Lord has made known to us.”
Luke 2:15

As we once again come together to celebrate our Saviour’s birth, we have chosen this lovely image of a precious young child, who is experiencing the Christmas celebration with eyes wide open, learning the stories, and singing the songs of our faith. 
The second reflection that I (Joy) would like to share from this picture is that time-honoured theme of mother and child, a theme that occupies my professional and personal life, and brings me a great deal of wonder.
Noel and I have come through 2012 with a wonderful sense of thanksgiving for life and love.
We pray that God will bless you in the coming year, and that you will know peace and strength in all of life’s challenges.
With love,
Joy and Noel

Saturday, December 15, 2012

hospital policy in the spotlight

Today as I write I have in mind a young midwife who is employed by a busy private hospital in Melbourne.  I hope that midwife comes to my blog, and reflects on the incident that I witnessed recently, and which I will briefly describe here.

The labouring woman had written a brief birth plan; the sort of plan that I call "Plan A".
Something like this:

I am intending to give birth under my own power, and will do all I can to achieve the best outcomes for myself and my baby.  At the time of birth, my baby’s cord should not be clamped or cut, and my baby must not be separated from me, except for clear medical reasons, and with my consent.  
I do not want any drugs to be administered to me or my baby without my consent. ...

"Yes, we do 'skin to skin', we do 'delayed cord clamping', and we keep babies with their mothers."
"But we can't do physiological third stage."
"The problem is," the young midwife said, "It's hospital policy that you have syntometrine.  I have checked with my manager, and we have to give you syntometrine for the placenta.  It's hospital policy."

The mother was labouring, wasn't saying much, so nothing was resolved.  The midwife brought the tray containing ampoules of the oxytocics into the room.

... fast forward  ...

A healthy baby made his grand entrance, and no drugs were used.  The woman birthed her placenta spontaneously about 30 minutes after the birth, with minimal blood loss.


I am recording this brief account because I want to comment on it.

  • A midwife became the pusher and enforcer of a hospital policy to administer a particular drug preparation.  This is not midwifery.  There was no professional discussion offered as to the implications of the use of this drug for mother or baby.  The midwife simply acted as an agent of her employer, demanding compliance with this policy.  
  • A midwife failed to recognise or uphold a woman's right to informed decision making, and ultimately her right of refusal.

I feel very concerned for this midwife, who is at the beginning of her career.   It seemed clear to me that the midwife considered it her job to enforce the policy.  The midwife gave no indication of any understanding of or interest in the physiology of birth.  Rather, she seemed set on carrying out a series of tasks that were, apparently, the essence of her professional practice. 

The midwife appeared to be ready to ignore a written statement by the woman, that she intended to give birth spontaneously, without drugs.  There seemed to be an assumption by the midwife that the woman's choice of working in harmony with physiological processes and avoiding unnecessary medications was a choice that could carry no weight in that particular hospital.   There was no discussion of the potential benefits or risks of either course of action.  'Hospital policy' was the big flashing light that apparently barred the woman from attempting her plan of action.

The prophylactic use of oxytocics in the third stage of labour, 'active management of third stage', is a process of routine intervention that comes under the banner of the 'evidence based practice' movement.  The uncritical adoption of active management by most hospitals, with the belief that it reduces blood loss and thereby reduces maternal morbidity, is rarely questioned.

In this birth, the mother was ideally suited to unmedicated, safe, physiological third stage because the following requirements had been met:
  • a woman in good health
  • at term
  • spontaneous onset of labour
  • good progress in labour
  • uncomplicated, unmedicated first and second stages of labour.

In contrast, there are good reasons why one might seek to avoid use of Syntometrine. 
Syntometrine is a preparation that combines synthetic oxytocin with ergometrine.
Syntometrine is an S4 drug - restricted to prescription by a doctor or an authorised midwife prescriber.  The idea that a hospital would make policy requiring the use of a restricted medicine is in itself suggestive of a breach of the basic rules of prescribing. 

Follow the link above to read consumer information about Syntometrine.  One small sentence stands out:  
Tell your doctor if you plan to breast-feed after being given Syntometrine. One of the ingredients in this medicine secretes into breast milk. Your doctor will discuss the potential risks and benefits involved.  (http://www.mydr.com.au/medicines/cmis/syntometrine-solution-for-injection )

Breastfeeding is an intrinsic part of physiological birth.
 
Further information on the use of Syntometrine in lactation comes from MIMS, the widely used medicines reference resource:
Use in lactation Of the two components, only ergometrine is known to pass into breast milk. The use of Syntometrine during lactation is not generally recommended.
Ergometrine is secreted into milk and the inhibitory effect of ergometrine on prolactin can cause a reduction in milk secretion. Syntometrine has the potential to cause serious adverse drug reactions in breastfed newborns/ infants. Postpartum women receiving Syntometrine should avoid breastfeeding at least 12 hours after the administration. Milk secreted during this period should be discarded. 
...
How many mothers are given this information prior to administration of Syntometrine?  Very few, I think.

I hope readers see the point I am making.  Today we are advocating a return to spontaneous breech birth, returing to the woman and her baby their right to unmedicated physiological birth.   Perhaps we also need a group of intelligent, well motivated consumers, to become activists for umnedicated, uninterrupted birth, from the onset of labour to the completion of the expulsion of the placenta and membranes and cessation of bleeding.


Your comments are welcome

Thursday, December 06, 2012

why breech births are important

I had a moment of clarity just the other day: Women who have breech babies, and for whom spontaneous vaginal breech birth (vbb) is an option, need MIDWIVES who are willing to be on call, and work with them to the full extent of midwifery as primary maternity care providers in their births.

But, I hear someone say, midwives have been deskilled in VBB,  Most breech babies in the past 20 years have been delivered by caesarean.  So how can a midwife consider herself competent?

And, I hear someone else say, surely the hospitals won't allow a midwife to 'manage' a breech birth.  Surely the senior obstetricians will take control?

Yes, these are valid points, but there's one other point - the point of my recent epiphany - that needs to be considered.  No matter how deskilled midwives and doctors are, the woman's body is, in many cases, ABLE to do the work.  Spontaneous birth, regardless of which pole is presenting, is just that: SPONTANEOUS.  Spontaneous means that the progress happens under the powers that are within the woman's body.

I don't want to sound ignorant or naive here, because I know there are specific complications with breech births that increase risk of neonatal morbidity.  An arm can impede progress: a midwife can manipulate the baby to free that arm.   A baby can be born with low Apgar scores: a midwife is able to provide resuscitation.   The knowledge that upright vbb works well has been circulated in midwifery circles for as long as I can remember.  I don't know when I first heard the old adages, "let the breech hang" and "hands off the breech".  One of the main questions in the exam I took in 1973, when I became a midwife, was all about breech births.  Yet the obstetric textbooks teach the lithotomy position; and the warmed towel to support the baby's body while the various manoeuvres which have the names of obstetricians (eg Lovesett, Mauriceau Smellie Veit ... - I haven't checked the spelling) are performed.

Since the publication of the Hannah (2001) Term Breech Trial, which had the almost immediate effect of channeling almost all breech babies to the operating theatre, midwives in my part of the world have had little experience with vbb.  Breech presentations occur at Term in about 4-5 of 100 births.  In my practice I have seen one or two most years, which is consistent with that rate.  I have followed the current best practice guidelines and sought out external cephalic version, which in at least half of the cases has done the trick.  I would be foolish to claim any special expertise in vbb.  Yet, with the information and drive I now have, I would now be prepared to discuss the option of spontaneous vbb at home in my care, or hospital, with any woman at Term with a breech baby on board. 

There are just a few birthing situations today that potentially challenge the skill, knowledge, and courage of a midwife.  These may be unanticipated.  They may occur with little warning.  And they require the midwife present at the time to act decisively in interests of safety of the mother and/or her baby.


A breech birth can be a big surprise.  The midwife can either act in harmony with the natural processes, and support uncomplicated birth of a healthy baby, or interrupt the processes and mechanisms of birth due to ignorance and fear.

Spontaneous birthing is the terrain in which midwives work best.  We watch and wait, and hold a cocoon of safety around the woman-child unit.  We know the subtle behaviours that indicate progress, and we know how to minimise adrenaline and other fear-related hormones.  We know how to leave well alone; how not to fiddle.  We know how to stay quietly with the woman, physically and emotionally, as she progresses on the pathway to bringing her child into this world.

Spontaneous birthing for vbb must be upheld and protected by midwives and women in all communities.  Sure, some of the big teaching hospitals need to set up breech clinics and have specialists strutting their stuff.  But the reality of childbearing is that women in small towns, and in outer suburbs, and on farms, will also occasionally need to give birth to breech babies.  Many won't have the $15,000 needed for a private hospital booking with the heavily booked breech doctor.  Many won't be within the catchment of the public hospital breech clinic.  They will need a midwife in their community who can work in harmony with a spontaneous and life giving process, and who has the skill to recognise complications in a timely manner and manage referral and transfer of care when it is indicated.

Does anyone out there see what I have seen?

Does anyone else feel deep sorrow for all the breech births for which we have not provided the option of midwifery care?

Midwives who are willing, we need to provide breech education for other midwives, and get the word out in women's groups that breech births can be great births. 

And, btw, we know that the promotion of spontaneous birth for breech babies will not necessarily be easy.  Midwives may need to provide arguments about women making informed choices in professional conduct hearings.   This is the world in which we live.



For more consumer-focused breech information, go to BBANZ . 


Saturday, December 01, 2012

Dueling Experts

This week, at the MIPP blog, I have recorded some of the questions asked in the course of a formal hearing into the conduct of a midwife.  The scene was a room in the County Court in Melbourne: formal, foreboding, and unfamiliar territory to the midwife whose actions in two particular cases were allegedly unprofessional.  The panel appointed to hear the case did not have anyone who could be called a peer.  Those three women also appeared to be in very unfamiliar territory.

Although formal hearings are open to the public, I have not identified the midwife or the witnesses who spoke for the Board or in the midwife's defense.  The name of the person who made the notifications (complaints) is suppressed by law, and the names of the women who received care from the midwife, leading to the complaints are also not allowed to be published.

In his opening address the lawyer acting for the Board ( Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia ) commented that this case will probably come down to 'dueling experts'.  The second time he used that phrase it sounded more like 'drooling experts'!  Whether it was intended as a joke or not, it's difficult to see the funny side when a colleague is having to undergo such grueling questions about births that took place more than 6 years ago.

There were two experts called to answer the questions put to them by the two lawyers.  Both experts are Professors of midwifery: highly respected women who have impressive academic credentials.   The arguments become polarised between risk and the woman's choice.

Expert 1 told the panel hearing the case that the risk of a twin birth, or a postmature birth, was too great to be managed in the woman's home by midwives. 'Risk' and 'safety' appeared to be synonymous.
 
Expert 2 told the panel that safety can only be achieved when the woman's right to choose is upheld and supported - even if the woman is giving birth to twins, or the pregnancy is postmature.




Have you ever listened to dueling banjos?  Take a moment to listen to this one from Youtube, played by John O'Connell with James Meall.

That's the image that came to me when the barrister said we faced dueling experts.
They start out slowly, deliberately.
One makes a statement.
The second answers.
Another statement, slightly more complicated.
Another answer.
And it continues until they are in full swing, and I think one or both must surely be lost.  I do not understand how one or the other 'wins' the duel - I think banjo players must have some rules about that. 

And so it is for midwives.

Is a midwife *allowed* to agree to homebirth when one or more risk factors have been identified?
Is a woman *allowed* to plan homebirth when one or more risk factors have been identified?

This is the question, ultimately, that this panel are required to answer.  The NMBA has a two-fold statutory role, to protect the public and to guide the profession.  The protection of the public, in this case, is about putting limits on midwives, and thereby putting limits on the women who engage our professional services.  The guidance of the profession is, in this case, about attempting to define the boundaries of a midwife's practice.

I have come away from this episode of dueling experts without any solution.
I agree with the second expert, who strongly asserted that safety can only be achieved when a mother's right to informed decision making is protected and upheld.
Yet I know well that midwives will continue to be challenged if they agree to operate 'on the fringe'.

Monday, November 26, 2012

TWO YEARS LATER

It's two years since November 2010, when the Australian government announced sweeping maternity reforms that promised to give women a better deal in their maternity care.  The Report of the Maternity Services Review acknowledged that:
"... in light of current evidence and consumer preference, there is a case to expand the range of models of maternity care."

There are several posts on this site addressing the 2008 Review, and the subsequent recommendations and legislative reform.  For example, go to March 2010 Maternity Reform Hijacked, parts 1, 2, and 3; and the September 2010 one on Medicare funding: carrot or poisoned chalice.

Many midwives around this country have accepted the challenge, jumped through all the hoops, and achieved notation as Medicare eligible.  Our invoices for antenatal and postnatal midwifery services include the Medicare item numbers, and women are able to obtain Medicare rebate.  Some midwives are offering certain services at the Medicare bulk bill rate, which involves the swipe of a Medicare card in a little EFTPOS machine; the entry of a few details using the numbers on the machine, and the bulk bill payment shows up in the midwife's nominated bank account the next day.

The other major change that was brought about by the reform package was the ability of midwives to prescribe certain scheduled drugs: drugs that at present only a doctor can prescribe.  The first group of students in the Graduate Diploma of Midwifery from Flinders University are soon to receive their final scores for the Pharmacology exam paper, which we sat last Thursday, and which accounts for 50% of the mark.  For my journal as a student, go to this and subsequent entries.

On the positive side of the 2-year report of the 'reform' process we can record Medicare.  For example, Item number 82115, with a scheduled fee of $313.05 is
Professional attendance by a participating midwife, lasting at least 90 minutes, for assessment and preparation of a maternity care plan for a patient whose pregnancy has progressed beyond 20 weeks,...
]
The Medicare statistics website reveals that, in the 12 months October 2011 to October 2012, a total of $325,005 was paid out by Medicare for Item #82115.
The breakdown of amounts is (in order of magnitude):
Queensland $114,010
Victoria $63,944
South Australia $55,081
NSW $44,308
WA $40,720
ACT $3,241
Tas $2,912
NT $788
This is only one item number.  Other reports can be generated at the Medicare Item Reports site.


On the negative side of the leger, there are several points to note.  This list is my personal one, made from my experience.


  1. Medicare Collaboration:
    It is becoming increasingly difficult in some areas to obtain collaborative arrangements that meet the requirements for midwives to provide Medicare rebates for women.
  2. Access to practising in public hospitals: Despite expert multi-disciplinary committees and meetings and reports, it's clear that public hospitals do not welcome the idea of midwives practising privately within their confines.
  3.  Access to practising in private hospitals: Are you kidding?
  4. The homebirth problem: Midwives attending homebirth are doing so without indemnity insurance.  Surely the time of birth, regardless of place, is the very time when insurance may be useful. 
  5. The future of private midwifery practice: I believe it is becoming more difficult over time to sustain private midwifery practice.  I believe some (probably well meaning) captains of the industry have an agenda to rid our society of homebirth.
Two years on, and the private midwifery profession is more restricted than it was previously.  There has been no expansion of the "range of models of maternity care" - the stated purpose of the maternity reforms.

*****

In conclusion, today I sat in a court room in Melbourne, as the case of complaints into the professional practice of a colleague was commenced by AHPRA.  The law under which the complaints are being heard prevents publication of the name of the complainant, and in this case the names of the women who employed the midwife have also been suppressed.

The legal inquiries and arguments will proceed over the coming days, and the midwife will eventually be told what findings have been made against her, and what conditions may be placed on her ability to practise her profession. [see MidwivesVictoria]

The issue that will, I believe, be at the centre of the case is whether a midwife is *allowed* to attend birth at home for a woman who has recognised risk factors.  The other side of that same coin is whether a woman who has risk factors, such as post maturity, previous caesarean, or twins, is *allowed* to give birth at home.  I have written *allowed* this way to highlight the statutory process that is being employed here, using the regulation of the profession to either permit or prevent certain activities, that are seen - rightly or wrongly - as 'operating on the fringe'.

I am not able in a blog to explore these issues fully.  I would like to make a clear statement that I consider the duty of care of the midwife who agrees to provide primary care for any woman, regardless of the risk status of that woman, to include the promotion of the wellbeing of mother and child, and where reasonable, the protection of spontaneous natural life processes.  The woman is the one who has the final choice on accepting or refusing any intervention.

The midwife practising privately brings skill and knowledge that may not be accessible or reliable in the hospital, where ad-hoc staffing issues often take precedence over the interests of the individual woman.

What progress have we made in the two years since the Maternity reform package was enacted?  Very little.  The only place most midwives are able to practise is the home.  The only way a woman can rely on a midwife is if she plans home birth.


Monday, November 12, 2012

rare birthing footage

http://youtu.be/8NLyORwJCOk

This youtube link is really worth watching.