Monday, July 06, 2009

Bill B


Tomorrow (Tues 7 July) I am planning to attend the Victorian stakeholders forum on 'Bill B', the exposure draft of the National Regulation and Accreditation Scheme for health professionals.

I have prepared a couple of documents exploring the clauses in the new legislation, and the impact that this is likely to have on midwives' private practices. Included is a list of questions to ask the representatives from the Department of Human Services at the forum tomorrow. If anyone would like me to send this information to you, please contact me by email joy@aitex.com.au. You will need to introduce yourself if I don't already know you, because I don't want to share my work with people who might abuse it.

You may wonder why I have included a picture of a Bilby, a small mouse-like marsupial with big ears?

Midwives share a lot with the Bilby. I'm suggesting that the Bilby be adopted by midwives as our little animal mascot.

The Bilby is at present being brought back from near-extinction. The midwife in private practice is also an endangered species. We need big ears, like the Bilby, to stay alert to any danger. We need to scurry for cover at the slightest sign.

Let's hope we have the resillience and intelligence to overcome the threats to our existence, and continue providing expert one-to-one midwifery care for women in our communities.


In the interests of best practice, and safe choices for all women, I believe:
• Midwives must be able to practise midwifery without government or outside professional interference
• No group of midwives should be subjected to greater levels of regulation than any other group of midwives – independent midwives expect the same degree of regulation as any other midwife
• The midwifery profession expects the same level of regulation as other health professions
• Peer counselling and confidential review of cases should be implemented. Midwives who are acting in a way that may be unprofessional or incompetent or putting their clients at risk should be reported to the regulatory body for investigation – as for any other professional.
• Risk assessment and response to development of complications is a normal aspect of a midwife’s professional capability. Risk assessment is an ongoing process throughout the episode of care. (WHO 1996 Care in normal birth)
• Women who seek the services of independent midwives will sometimes have complex social and obstetric histories, and this makes the dedicated care of a skilled midwife essential. This option is often not available in hospital based models of care, private or public.
• We need urgently to demolish the barriers that exist in maternity care, preventing midwives from attending their clients privately in hospitals.
• The protection of the midwife’s right to attend a woman privately for maternity care in any setting is strongly in the public interest.

Thursday, July 02, 2009

ABC Radio - Life Matters

As if to celebrate the expected demise of private midwifery and homebirth by this time next year, the ABC Radio's Life Matters program has presented an outrageous interview with Dr Hilary Joyce, the new president of the College of Obstetricians and Gynae's.

You can listen to the podcast here.

I have left a comment at the guestbook.

I would like to suggest that midwives working privately should be treated no differently from doctors or other professionals working privately.

Many women who employ a midwife want to know the person who will be with them throughout their active labour, promoting normal birth, and supporting them to make informed decisions. This is best practice in midwifery, yet it's as scarce as hen's teeth in the public system. That's why women employ midwives privately. There is nothing synister about homebirth. Evidence from international and Australian homebirths shows clearly that homebirth is a reasonable choice for well women with a midwife primary carer who is able to refer to obstetric specialists if and when complications arise.

Most midwives in private practice are highly competent midwives, and we have excellent outcomes. I am one. I have practised privately for the past 15+ years, and I stand to lose my livelihood next year because I can't purchase professional indemnity insurance.

The bias of the guest Dr Hilary Joyce in this interview was not explored. The claims linking Australia's maternity obstetrics with obstetric oversight of birth cannot be supported. An outcome for which obstericians are primarily responsible is that more than 30% of Australian babies are born by caesarean surgery.

Obstetricians do not practise midwifery; midwives do not practise obstetrics. The midwife has, by definition, a duty to promote normal birth. The obstetrician is a surgeon, who should be consulted only when illness or complication arise in pregnancy or birth.

Remember, pregnancy and birth are not an illness.

You can read comments, and leave your own at Life Matters Guestbook.

Wednesday, July 01, 2009

1 July 2009



I want to mark this day, 1 July 2009.

In just twelve months from today privately practising midwives who don’t have insurance will be called ‘non-practising midwives’ under the new national Health Practitioner Registration laws. New arrangements will provide indemnity insurance for eligible midwives to practise other parts of midwifery, but NOT homebirth. Homebirth is the livelihood of self employed, privately practising midwives.

The new laws and provisions will potentially open up new freedom for midwives employed by hospitals; an item for celebration. Even homebirth may be provided by the hospitals - the insurance will be provided as part of the employer's vicarious liability arrangements.

It will be confusing and dangerous for consumers, and we need to do all we can to prevent this ill-thought-out health reform from progressing without amendment to enable a midwife to practise midwifery in any setting, which is fundamental to the international definition of the midwife.


Friday, June 26, 2009

in summary ...

From Health Minister Nicola Roxon: Historic Step forward for Midwives and Nurse Practitioners

From Australian College of Midwives: Mothers and babies at risk: Access to qualified midwives for homebirth under threat

From Maternity Coalition (by email - website not updated at the time of writing this blog) "Maternity Coalition’s vision is for all Australian women to choose who, where and how they birth. We are about increasing women’s choices so they can make informed decisions about the type of care that is right for them and their family. We are facing the prospect of having an evidence-based model of care being removed – and why? It would be an understatement to say we are concerned about this. We are VERY concerned about this."

From Homebirth Australia: "Deaths will increase with new announcements" ... "We believe every woman has the right to choose how and where she gives birth. Please stop homebirth becoming illegal and sign our online petition."

From Midwives in Private Practice (MiPP): "Can the Australian maternity community accept government interference in defining the setting of practice of a midwife? Would the medical community accept such wanton interference in its professional boundaries?"

Midwife-blogger Lisa Barrett: "I am a failure to understand why all women and midwives are totally up in arms at this. I know they aren't because many see it as better than nothing. That's really all midwives are good for, scraps from the Obs table. If every midwife decided to stop work for the day in protest then it would soon change."

Blogger Hoyden About Town "Homebirth to become illegal in a year. ... And no matter how low-risk the woman nor how much she desires a homebirth, women will not be allowed to do so legally with a midwife. Because the legislation introduced this week will ban midwives from practising without insurance; and there is no insurance provider for homebirth midwives. So long, too bad, so sad. Good bye."

Save Homebirth blog: offering support for people travelling to Canberra to protest at the Homebirth Australia Mother of All Rally, Monday 7 September.

Blogger-midwife Melissa Maimann: Access For Pregnant Women To Medicare Funded Midwifery Care On The Way: But not for homebirths

Thursday, June 25, 2009

PLEASE sign a petition to save private midwifery and homebirth

GO to the petition

"... with planned national registration of all health professionals to take effect on July 1st 2010 midwives in private practice will be unable to seek registration on the basis of their inability to obtain professional indemnity insurance."
The petition asks that "the senate bring this issue to the parliament's attention and make a speedy redress to assist midwives in private practice to obtain professional indemnity insurance. We also ask that midwives in private practice enjoy the same funding mechanisms as procedural general practitioners and specialist obstetricians under the medicare benefits schedule."

The petition is at the excellent new Homebirth Australia website.

Saturday, June 20, 2009

not interested in anything less

I was preparing a reply to a comment in the next post, and have brought it to a new post, as the issue needs more critical exploration.

The writer stated that the care of a private midwife has suited her well, and she is not interested in anything less. That is understandable, and I believe many women - and many independent midwives for that matter, agree.

But in any society the choices that we have are defined by laws set down by government, and the Australian government - the previous Liberal one, as well as the current Labor one - have agreed that it's in the public's interest to require all health professionals to have indemnity insurance. After 1 July next year women will not be able to access independent midwifery for homebirth (unless changes are made to the legislation or to the accessibility of indemnity insurance for midwives).

The only profession for which indemnity insurance is not available for private practice is midwifery. This is a global phenomenon. Countries where midwives practise autonomously (and are not under threat as Australian midwives are) - Netherlands, Canada, and New Zealand, for example, have insurance schemes that are supported by government funds. New Zealand's system requires a percentage of the earnings of all health professionals to be placed in an accident compensation fund, from which payments are made to any patient or client who experiences harm. This is very different from Australia's system, in which anyone who claims they have been harmed in their health care has to sue their doctor/midwife/hospital in a court of law, or come to an arrangement (payout) prior to going to court.

It is unreasonable to ask that one section of the health care community, independent midwifery, have different rules than the rest. I believe a scheme similar to the New Zealand scheme, would bring equity into the maternity system, and take decisions about compensation out of the courts. Of course matters of professional misconduct or negligence would need to be dealth with at a higher level, as they are currently, and will be under the new Health Practitioner legislation.

The 'decision' that midwives providing homebirth independently should not be indemnified, and consequently the outlawing of privately attended homebirths is a decision of the current Health Minister, Nicola Roxon. She needs to hear from every person who cares, and she needs to change that decision. We, the public, have the right to tell our elected representatives, what we consider to be reasonable.

Friday, June 19, 2009

talking about homebirth

Thismorning I was woken by someone from ABC Radio 774 (the Melbourne local radio) at about 6.30. Would I speak to Red Simon about homebirth being outlawed?
Sure.
They called back, and Red wanted to know about homebirth. In the next few minutes (cut short mysteriously by the phone line going dead) I was able to reassure him of the safety of homebirth.
Red sounded genuinely surprised that 30% of Dutch babies can be born at home in this century. I think he was wanting to paint a picture of homebirth being a vestige of a bygone era, that some of us are reluctant to part with. He told me his wife went to three different hospitals to have her three children, so that she could check out the cuisine. He asked me if my children were born at home. No - I didn't know about homebirth then. I learnt about homebirth from reading professional literature. It was the evidence that convinced me.

News articles discussing the future of homebirth have appeared in several papers thismorning.
Daily Telegraph (Sydney) informs us that "HOMEBIRTHS will become illegal under tough new laws that prevent women using midwives to have children outside hospitals. The move is set to drive homebirths underground, with expectant mothers and their babies at risk."
A similar article in Adelaide Now identifies "the draft Health Practitioner Regulation National Law, released last week, [under which] a midwife cannot be registered unless she has insurance."

For more detail, please go to the MiPP blog.

It's not true that *all* homebirth will be illegal after 1 July 2010, when the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law, which mandates professional indemnity insurance as a condition for registration, is set to come into effect.

Homebirth programs that are operated by hospitals and health authorities will be able to continue. The option that will become illegal is private arrangements between a woman and a midwife. That means midwives like me, and an estimated 150 others, will be out of work, and all the women who want to arrange homebirth privately will be denied that choice.

Depending on your perspective, here are some ideas. I present them as questions, because each person with an interest in homebirth will have to make the best decision they can when the time comes.

After 1 July next year:
Will a midwife agree to provide midwifery care 'underground', and ask the parents and anyone else involved to keep quiet about their role?
Will a midwife who continues 'underground' cease any reporting to governement authorities such as Registry of Births, Deaths and Marriages, and perinatal data collection units?
Will a midwife who continues 'underground' ask for cash payments, and cease reporting income to the Tax Office?
Will a woman who wants homebirth need to arrange her own documentation of the birth - either by statutory declaration, or by arriving at a public hospital with her baby, and stating that the baby was 'born before arrival'?
Will a woman who wants homebirth and who experiences complications at home need to go to hospital without her midwife's referral or support?
Will all the women who want to plan homebirth find doctors who will attend them at home?

The doctor issue is worth thinking about. It might sound like competitive rivalry for me to bring doctors into this discussion, but the fact is that independent midwives compete with doctors to be the primary carers for pregnant/birthing women. (it's a very unlevel playing field, but that's another issue!) While the midwife offers continuity of care throughout the pregnancy and birth, the local GP offers a variety of fragmented models of 'shared care', ensuring that the woman receives care from a midwife who is a total stranger in labour. The stranger-midwife is also a feature of models in which an obstetrician is the primary care provider.

There are doctors who support homebirth; some have given birth at home themselves, while others will agree to attend homebirths. Melbourne doctor Peter Lucas is well known and appreciated for his homebirth practice.

Doctors have indemnity insurance, so they will be able to continue practising after 1 July next year. Some have insurance that covers 'procedures' - including childbirth, while others are more restricted in what they are able to do. Doctors fees are rebatable through Medicare, and the Medicare Safety Net enables the doctor to charge a fee that he/she considers appropriate, knowing that the client will be able to get a lot of it back from the public purse.

Women could, en masse, require attendance at home from doctors for home births if midwives are not able to be called. Of course the doctors might refuse to attend, but what is their duty of care in such a situation?

Another question: will public hospitals set up homebirth services that will provide the required professional care for all the women who at present would book with an independent midwife? Will the hospitals provide employment (and indemnity) for independent midwives?


These questions are all in my mind. What will I do? How will I advise women who ask me? (And, from a practical point of view, How will I earn enough to keep food on the table?)

Monday, June 15, 2009

Being Baby Friendly


[Pic: Barb and Cassie, used with permission]

On Saturday I attended an update session for assessors and educators in the Baby Friendly Health Initiative (BFHI). I have been involved with BFHI since it was introduced to Australia in the early 1990s, and it was good to focus on the issues of promoting, protecting and supporting breastfeeding in our maternity care system.

The BFHI is an international project that aims to give every baby the best start in life by creating a health care environment where breastfeeding is the norm and practices known to promote the health and well-being of all babies and their mothers are followed.

The BFHI Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding are the global standard by which health services are assessed and accredited. A 'Baby Friendly' health service is one where mothers' informed choice of feeding is supported, respected and encouraged.

In Australia, the Australian College of Midwives administers the Baby Friendly Health Initiative.


The BFHI has released a new set of booklets which will be used for health facility (usually hospital) assessments in the future. A few issues that were open to interpretation in the past have been clarified. Acceptable medical reasons for the use of breastmilk substitutes, and Standards for compliance with the World Health Organisation International Code of Marketing of breastmilk substitutes (known as the 'WHO Code' ) are clearly stated. It is likely that some 'Baby Friendly' hospitals will need to improve their policies and practices before their next assessment in order to maintain the award.

Here are a few of *my* highlights taken from the revised BFHI assessment. Please note, this list is not exclusive:
(For the full wording of each Step, click here
Step 1: The facility's breastfeeding policy is supported by clinical protocols which are evidence based.

Step 2: At least 80% of staff who assist mothers with breast feeding are able to describe two issues that should be discussed with a pregnant woman or mother who indicates that she is considering feeding her baby with infant formula.

Step 3: The antenatal education includes the importance of skin to skin contact for all babies (not just those whose mothers plan to breastfeed!) for at least the first hour of life.

Step 4: The facility has procedures which keep mothers and babies together in skin to skin contact for at least an hour after a vaginal or caesarean birth. (medically indicated procedures which vary this policy are stated)

Step 5: Mothers who are not breastfeeding confirm that they have been given individual education about artificial feeding

Step 6: At least 80% of staff who assist with breastfeeding or who provide advice on breastfeeding are able to describe two pieces of information that they will discuss with a pregnant woman or mother who is undecided, but considering feeding her baby with infant formula.

Step 7: All babies stay with their mothers 24-hours a day. Documentation will be expected for any variation from this.

Step 8: Breastfeeding on demand (without restrictions or controls on frequency or length of feeding) is the standard, with emphasis on effective breastfeeding.

Step 9: Mothers can explain why dummy use is discouraged while breastfeeding is being established.

Step 10: The facility reports on how it works with local breastfeeding support groups and services.

Friday, June 05, 2009

We live in interesting times

I would like to add to my recent discussion and state here that I believe there is a positive future for homebirth, on a much larger scale than the Australian community has known.

Any major reform requires costings and processes to be carefully developed so that it is introduced in a responsible and transparent manner. I know that there is a lot of work happening behind the scenes at the national level to address the detail for the changes that were announced by the Health Minister in the Budget. Also state and territory health departments are working on policies for homebirth and water birth. South Australia has its policies published, and I think some of the other states are also moving ahead well in this area. If anyone reading this blog knows of web links for relevant policies, please pass them on either through the comments or by email joy@aitex.com.au

Although the midwifery reforms announced in the Budget (indemnity, Medicare and PBS) are hugely significant to independent midwives and the women who employ us, the reforms are a lifeline to the whole midwifery profession. The midwife's scope of practice in all settings will be freed from some of the unreasonable restrictions that have all but stifled the profession and prevented midwives from practising as defined in the ICM Definition of the Midwife.

I anticipate that, from November 2010, midwifery will move from the obstetrician's-assistant- shiftworker-nurse model to that of a distinct professional who has authority for a unique model of care in which the woman and her known midwife primary carer work in a special partnership, with the purpose of promoting health of both mother and baby through the promotion and protection of physiological processes linked to normal birth and nurture of infants.

I anticipate that Medicare payments will enable health services to set up a range of options that are attractive to both mothers and midwives, in which midwives provide primary maternity care for women, integrating their care with the specialist obstetric and other medical services in the hospitals as and when needed. There will be no need for the cost shifting that goes on now, with women being sent to doctors for the prenatal care to take pressure off the hospital budget.

I anticipate that university midwifery departments will celebrate the reduction of the theory-practice gap that has plagued them for many years. The career options for midwives who want to practise midwifery will be greatly expanded.


I have been in touch with Patrice Hickey, Victorian branch President of the Australian College of Midwives, (ACM Vic) and I would like to acknowledge the work of the ACM throughout this process on behalf of midwives and birthing women.

We live in interesting times!

Tuesday, June 02, 2009

HOMEBIRTH after July 2010???

I am writing today with a foggy brain that didn't assume the horizontal until after two thismorning. But that's what midwives do, after all. I do hope this brief discussion makes sense.

We (the community of independent midwives and homebirth parents) are all wondering what will happen to homebirth after July next year. If you are not aware of the issues, please scroll down in this blog, and go to the MIPP blog for more information and links.

I've been busy with a cluster of births, and haven't had time to be worried yet, but I know some of my clients are concerned. I just have lots of unanswered questions, such as ...

What will be the impact of the midwifery changes announced in the federal budget on my ability to practice midwifery (and make a living)?
(I am writing in the first person here - that's what people seem to do on their blogs - but I know it applies well beyond my personal situation!)

With the requirement for indemnity insurance for registration from 1 July 2010, and the government's provision of indemnity insurance &c for 'eligible midwives' from 1 November 2010, what happens to my ability to earn a living, and to the women who want me to attend them professionally, during those four months? (assuming that the announced time frame will be adhered to) How can I be sure that I will be an eligible midwife?

and the BIG question:
WHAT ABOUT HOMEBIRTH?

There are no publicly funded homebirth options in my area, and even if there were, some women would prefer to engage a midwife privately to come into their home to provide midwifery services. Some women booked with me would be excluded from any service that is 'risk managed' to current hospital standards - those who have had more than six babies (they should be considered super birthers by that stage), those who have had one or more previous caesareans, those whose babies don't want to be born before that magical 42 week mark, those who are a bit too old, a bit too young, to tall, too short, or whatever.

Does this mean that I am ignorant or careless about risk?
Does this mean that women who choose my care are being ignorant or careless about their own safety or the safety of their babies?

I'm not going to say a blanket no, or yes. It all depends. No life event, and particularly not birth, can be risk free. Home and hospital both have their own sets of risks and uncertainties.


I don't know what's going to happen about homebirth.

I would encourage anyone who is interested to work at keeping yourself informed, and to take action in whatever way you can.
Keep an eye on the blogs, forums, email groups, and professional journals that are writing about midwifery and homebirth.
Read everything with a critical eye.
Be prepared to ask how would [ ] affect me - the political is personal.

Think globally,
Act locally.

and


Plan if you can to attend the Homebirth Rights rally in Canberra, 7 September, and tell others about it.

Saturday, May 30, 2009

breastfeeding difficulties in the first fortnight

Today I want to reflect on the journeys of two first time mothers and their babies. Although these 'cases' are based on two actual babies and their mothers, the situations are not uncommon, and I hope this account will assist readers in understanding better the complexity and the wonder of the natural processes in nourishing and nurturing newly born babies.

I will call the babies Baby Boy (BB) who weighed about 3.4 kilos, and Baby Girl (BG) who weighed about 4 kilos at birth. Both were born in public hospitals in Melbourne, receiving good midwifery care. Both mothers pushed their babies out under their own steam, so to speak - spontaneous vaginal births. The mother of BG had received an injection of a narcotic a few hours prior to the birth, and the mother of BB received several doses of an oral narcotic after the birth.

Both babies remained skin-to-skin with their mothers for their first hour or so, but neither breast fed in that period. BG's mother was taken to the operating theatre for removal of her placenta, and BB's mother was taken to the operating theatre for repair of a perineal tear. Both babies slept while separated from their mothers.

By 24 hours -
Baby BB had had a couple of brief breast feeds but was still quite sleepy most of the time.
Baby BG had been to the breast several times, without attaching well. She was sucking her lower lip when awake, and seemed content with that.

By 48 hours, second day -
Both mothers and babies had gone home from hospital. Neither of the babies was feeding effectively.

I was in contact with both mothers. I encouraged each to work on learning to express milk by hand, to 'reward' any effort made by her baby with expressed milk, and to give baby as much as she was able to express. This amounted to not much more than a few mililitres. The mother was encouraged to persevere with massaging and expressing her breasts every few hours until her baby's efforts at suckling became strong and effective.

Third day -
Baby BG was checked by hospital midwife. Although she had not yet breastfed effectively, she was receiving about 5 ml of expressed colostrum milk whenever she was awake. Both mother and baby were well. Mother was encouraged to continue, and to give BG access to her breast when ever she was awake.

Baby BB had not woken much, and his mother had kept to the plan of expressing her colostrum every 3-4 hours, and giving him the milk using a syringe or tea spoon. However, that evening the result of BB's serum bilirubin test indicated moderate jaundice, which was at the lower end of the range for which babies of his age are nursed in phototherapy. The hospital nurse called BB's mother, and asked her to bring him to the special care nursery, to be admitted. BB's mother asked if she would be able to stay to continue breastfeeding, and was told 'no'. There was no bed available. The hospital would use any expressed breast milk she provided, as well as artificial formula milk to feed BB while he was in their care.

At the same time, I was visiting BB and his mother. We worked at stimulating little BB, using olive oil to massage him, and co-bathing in the bath tub. We were delighted when he cooperated, and took both breasts better than he had done previously. The mother was not willing to be separated from BB without good reason, and we felt we had turned a corner. With my support the parents made the decision to stay at home, and have BB's jaundice checked again at the hospital the following day.

I had noted that BB was tongue tied, and arranged for the hospital breastfeeding support unit to review that too. BB did a lot of serious breastfeeding overnight, and when his serum bilirubin (jaundice) level was checked the next day he was out of the range requiring admission.

Fourth day -
Baby BG had found the breast, to the delight of her parents. However her mother's nipples were grazed and ridges were forming across the nipple when she nursed. When I visited them I guided mother with a few tips on improving the positioning and attachment - fine tuning the success that they had achieved on their own.

Baby BB also seemed to be progressing well. He and his mother spent the day with the breast feeding support midwife at the hospital. The frenulum (tongue tie) was snipped; the jaundice was settling; the number of wet and pooey nappies increased; and he was settling and sleeping between feeds.

Baby BB's mother was confident to cease expressing milk by about Day 5. However, over the next few days it became clear that his breastfeeding was not as effective as BB needed, as he did not gain any weight from the fourth to the tenth day. He was going to the breast frequently, but often unsettled after feeds. The Maternal and Child health nurse assessed him as dehydrated, considered that the tongue tie was continuing to interfere with BB's sucking, and insisted that he be given baby formula milk supplements. Attempts to express milk by hand and using an electric breast pump resulted in small amounts - about 10 ml.

That evening I visited baby BB and his mother, and once again we devised a plan. This included learning a more effective bi-manual compression of the breast, and regular expressing to stimulate milk production. All expressed milk was given to BB after he had worked at the breast. The record of feeds showed a steady increase in the volume of breastmilk that was given as a supplement to BB.

By about 12 days of age BB's efforts at the breast continue to be supplemented with expressed milk. The tongue tie is to be reviewed by another doctor who is expert in such matters. Mother continues to work consistently on increasing her milk supply. Her beautiful baby boy is responding well: the more milk she gives him, the more he wants.


As I reflect on these real life situations that real mothers and their babies face I am very pleased to record the stories. The issues in getting breastfeeding right are as multi-faceted as any other aspect of life. Each mother-baby pair have their own set of challenges; some expected, and some out of the blue. Each mother-baby pair who manage to overcome their challenges and make the best choices that are available at the time are learning about life and becoming more strongly bonded together. The resulting emotional attachment supports them in dealing with the life challenges that lie ahead.


Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Generation Y birthing


Young and beautiful mummies and daddies, bringing beautiful babies into the world.
Texting their messages in labour, telling a multitude of 'friends' how they feel on facebook, twittering, with baby's website being set up while the labour progresses.

Oh yes, it's not just Gen Y who do it. But, they (Gen Y that is) do it so 'naturally'.

Friday, May 22, 2009

Am I Responsible?

'Am I Responsible?' was the theme of the professional study day presented by the Australian Nursing Federation in Carlton today.

Case studies were presented as examples of the complexities that nurses and midwives face in situations where their professional actions are investigated. Coroner Audrey Jamieson explained the Coroner's role in seeking answers when a death is investigated. Barrister Ron Gipp described legal respresentation given for a nurse who was required to attend the Coroner's Court. Nurses Board CEO, Nigel Fidgeon, presented the Board's role in investigations into professional conduct.

I am interested in these matters, and value the opportunity to consider the issues from the perspective of health care professionals generally. On occasions when I accompany a woman to hospital I am able to observe the practice culture of the unit, as well as the behaviours of individual staff members.

I have recently had reason to be very concerned about what appears to be a culture of carelessness concerning drug administration in a hospital maternity unit. The young midwife had reached the end of her shift and said to the midwife who was replacing her, "I have drawn up the Syntocinon (oxytocic). It's in the fridge (and pointed to the small fridge in the room)." The second midwife seemed happy with that, and did not make any comment.

There was no emergency situation. Baby had been born 30 minutes previously, and mother and baby were well. There was no bleeding. The mother had requested physiological Third Stage.


Hospitals may not have a 'guideline' or 'protocol' on physiological Third Stage. Most hospitals promote active management of the Third Stage. Many midwives in hospitals have had little experience with any part of physiological birth.

I am not criticising the fact that the drug had been drawn up. I am critical of the casual handover from one midwife to the next. There have been far to many cases when the wrong drug has been administered. In birthing suites there have been tragic cases such as mistaken administration of a dose of Syntometrine (Syntocinon and Ergometrine, a common oxytocic mixture used in Third Stage) to a woman in labour, in stead of an analgesic such as Pethidine. The oxytocic had been drawn up 'early' and kept on hand. When Pethidine was also drawn up but the standard checking and adminsitration by two midwives had not been followed, the mistake had taken place.


I had a quiet word with the midwife, and explained my concerns. There was no adverse event at the time, but I hope that by drawing attention to the matter I will be preventing tragic mistakes at some other time. Midwives who administer any medicine or substance to women in our care have a duty of care to take full professional precautions in every instance. Once we step outside 'Plan A' - spontaneous, unmedicated birth - and use drugs and other medical interventions, the risks to both mother and baby are upped. A midwife's competence in management of these medical substances and procedures is, for that woman, just as important as her competence in promoting normal birth.

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

silence

I wonder why virtually noone is making any comment about the midwifery changes announced in last Tuesday's budget - indemnity, Medicare and limited prescribing?

The silence covers the newspapers, TV and radio programs that I have accessed, as well as midwifery and maternity-related email lists. I have been with labouring women in two Melbourne hospitals this week - Mercy and Box Hill - and most of the midwives I have spoken to were not aware that anything has happened. Others seem scared that the reforms will be subjected to excessive gatekeeping, effectively setting hurdles that are too high for ordinary midwives to aspire to, and creating a two-tiered midwifery workforce.

I expected at least a few comments on blogs, but on the whole I'm hearing silence.

Midwife Lisa Barrett has put her opinion on her blog. I have left a comment there, and most of what appears below is copied to this site.

Although I am disappointed and frustrated that homebirth has been sectioned off as a 'no-go' zone, for reasons that can not be taken seriously by anyone who understands evidence, I am really pleased that the government has taken such a big step to dismantle the medical monopoly of maternity care. And in my mind the announcements of reform were more wonderful in the wake of the report of the maternity services review which said a lot of nothing and skirted around the real issues.

The budget press releases from the College of Midwives, as well as from Maternity Coalition and Homebirth Australia were, imho, worded in a politically correct way. I am confident that ACM is the best representative we have for midwives, and I have been assured that the defining of such things as advanced practice and collaboration will be acceptable even to ordinary midwives like me who don't have even a bachelor degree, let alone higher academic quals.

I am also wondering what will be done about homebirth in situations or locations where the publicly funded models are not available. I expect there will be some midwives prepared to go 'underground', while others will seek to comply with the new rules. Noone can force a woman to go to hospital.

I have been actively working for maternity reform since 1993 when I started my private practice. We have a long way to go, but from where I sit the 2009 federal budget is the biggest step forward that I have seen so far in my lifetime. I hope the bill passes in the Senate, and I hope those who represent midwives' and women's interests in bringing in the reforms will be wise and courageous.

I have many questions, and I, like others, will have to exercise patience. That's not easy. I have enjoyed the independence that I have had in midwifery in the past 15 or so years. I accept that there will be changes in how I can practise, if at all, after the middle of next year. I hope that by the end of this year I will still be taking bookings for births beyond 1 July.

Friday, May 15, 2009

BIG reforms for midwifery in Australia

I was on the job, 'with woman', when the announcement was made by the federal Treasurer Wayne Swan in his 2009 Budget speech to Parliament. Please go to the MiPP blog for press releases and more information.

This is a HUGE step forward in reforming maternity care for all women in Australia.

The following statement is from the Department of Health website:

12 May 2009

The 2009-10 Budget includes a $120.5 million package of measures to improve choice and access to maternity services for pregnant women and new mothers in Australia.

As a result of this package, families will have greater choice in the type of care they wish to receive when having a baby. The package also recognises the important role played by qualified midwives in the birthing experience of many Australian women.

Responding to the recently completed national Maternity Services Review, the package includes:

* Medicare Benefits Schedule and Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS) benefits for services provided by eligible midwives, to provide greater access to maternity care provided by midwives working in collaboration with doctors – expanding choice for women.
* A Government-supported professional indemnity insurance scheme for eligible midwives.
* More services for rural and remote communities, where the state of maternity services is poor, through an expansion of the successful Medical Specialist Outreach Assistance Program (MSOAP).
* Extra scholarships for GPs and midwives to expand the maternity workforce, particularly in rural and remote Australia.
* A new 24 hour, seven days a week telephone helpline and information service to provide women, their partners and families with greater access to maternity information and support before and after birth.

These arrangements will be subject to agreement with states and territories on a National Maternity Services Plan – who will be asked to make complementary commitments and investments, particularly around the provision of birthing centres and rural maternity units.

The Government’s commitment to a National Maternity Services Plan recognises the importance attached to maternity services by the over 270,000 Australian women who give birth each year, and their families.



At this early stage it is impossible to predict the detail of the new scheme, which is to be introduced from 1 November 2010. (If anyone has questions that you would like discussed, please leave a message in the comments section.) Here are a few points:

* The Australian College of Midwives is 'at the table' with the Health Minister and her department, representing midwives. All midwives would be well advised to get your ongoing professional education systems up to date, using the ACM Mid-PLUS program.

* Maternity Coalition is seeking to represent consumer interests in advocating for women's choice in birthing their babies.

* Homebirth Australia is well positioned to lobby for women's rights to give birth in the setting of their choice, including their own home.

* Local lobby groups such as Homebirth in the Hills, natural parenting groups, and Save Birth Choices have an important role in educating mothers and the general public, and in encouraging activism at a local level.


I know that many blog readers have contacted their local MPs and spoken to them in relation to the Maternity Services Review. Thankyou for your work. I would like to encourage you to keep yourselves well informed, write letters to the editors of newspapers, call radio talk back programs ... keep maternity care as a topic worth thinking about.

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Little one

Tell me what you see, little one,
When the world you know has so suddenly changed.
People coming and going.
And bright lights.
Do you also see tears in my eyes?

Tell me what you hear, little one?
In a world that changes without care of you.
Different people,
Different places.
Do you also hear the voice of love?

Is that your mother's milk on your tongue, little one?
Nurture and warmth.
Blood on your head:
Distance, separation, and fear?
Reality so different from what you instinctively seek.

Loving you so imperfectly,
there are times when the best I have is to cry with you.
Yet in that poor loving you learn living.

May God be with you, to guide and bless you, little one, as you start life's journey.


Joy Johnston, May 2009

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Being born is important

When you are able to take a moment for reflection, please go to Marina's blog to read this beautiful poem.

Marina is a midwife in Chiapas, Mexico.

The universal nature of deep truth about life, such as the truth so beautifully expressed in this poem, reminds me that we who know birth are the keepers and guardians of a precious treasure.

Sunday, May 10, 2009

Happy Mother's Day

... to all mothers, mothers to be, and any others reading this!


I would like to dedicate this blog to my mother, Ella White, who died 10 May 1985. The picture shows me with three of my (5) sisters: (L-R) Marion Andrews, Jane Ganter, and Annette Enchelmaier.


Today we have enjoyed a traditional family Sunday dinner after church. With a lovely white table cloth, a candle in the middle of the table, using the good crockery and cutlery, the meal was complete with roast chicken and veges, and followed by a lovely dessert, prepared my our daughter Bec.

Having family members around the table is something so basic to a mother that we can easily overlook its importance. Since my four young ones have left the nest, and set up their own homes, I treasure these special meal times. Sometimes we have to extend the table and find extra chairs; in good weather we set up tables al fresco on the deck.


A client phoned thismorning to tell me how disappointed she was; that she had thought her labour was getting underway last night. Contractions were coming regularly every six minutes for a couple of hours. Eventually she went to bed. It had all fizzled. AGAIN!

I reassured her. Her body is preparing for labour; not quite ready yet. I expect we will see this baby soon.

The final days of waiting for labour can be very difficult. It doesn't surprise me that induction of labour is frequently carried out for 'other' than valid reasons. Its not just the mother who can feel disappointed or frustrated in waiting for that indefinable tipping point. The midwife or doctor can find all sorts of reasons why, from a practical, time management point of view, it is reasonable to induce a labour.

However, the finely balanced processes that are orchestrated in normal labour and birth can be terribly disturbed with induction of labour. One intervention leads to another, and quickly the cascade of interventions become the driving force. Once the process has been started there is no going back.

I remember those nights in late pregnancy when I felt secretly hopeful that something was going to happen. I remember the doubts that came up in my mind: will I labour? will I know I am in labour? (silly questions, I know, but that didn't stop them from coming)

I think this mental turmoil is part of our instinctive nesting. We become unsettled, and perhaps difficult to live with. We become self absorbed.
That's good.
The labour will establish, and the child will be born.

Thursday, May 07, 2009

Baby born in a church

'Instant baby delivered in Church'
Here is fascinating footage from youtube, recording the birth of a baby girl in an African church.

The sound and visual quality is poor, but the story is clear. Two young mothers went to the church and were placed in the 'emergency section' to receive special prayer. As the minister prayed for them, one stood up and quickly gave birth to her baby on the concrete floor. She later testifies that she had been told she had a problem with jaundice, and that her baby was obstructed. She felt the baby move into position and she gave birth.

The woman sitting next to her had asked for prayer because her pregnancy was overdue. She testified that, having witnessed the birth in church, she went home and gave birth to a healthy baby boy (whose boy parts were displayed for the record) without any problems.


Most of my readers know of my Christian faith. Although I do not share the charismatic type of religious practice that is obvious in this video clip, I am able with all my heart to praise God for these births to young women in Lagos, Nigeria.

Many midwifery writers and thinkers have drawn attention to the ecstatic, out of body experience that can be part of normal birthing. We have come to understand that in advanced labour a woman's conscious, thinking mind - the neocortex - needs to be quiet, to free her to work with her body's intuitive, instinctive abilities which are based in the deeper part of her brain. In drawing together what I know as a midwife and as a mother who has given birth without medical stimulants or painkillers, with the power I know we have in prayer to the one true God who created us, I am not surprised when I witness this amazing ecstatic birthing.

Tuesday, May 05, 2009

HAPPY INTERNATIONAL MIDWIVES' DAY



[Print: thanks to artist and mother Emma Flaim]


My greetings to all midwives, and to all who value the work of midwives.



International Day of the Midwife – 5 May 2009
The World Needs Midwives Now More Than Ever!