Tuesday, April 26, 2011

The making of a midwife


I have recently finished reading Patricia Harman's memoir (pictured here), Arms wide open: a midwife's journey. I have enjoyed the journey.

As I progressed through the book I welcomed insight into the way Patsy, an idealistic hippy wild child in the early 1970s, learnt about life and in that learning, she found midwifery.

I welcomed insight into the realities of the American counter-culture, war resisters, commune life, living without what most of their peers would call the basic necessities of life.

I welcomed the honesty of statements by Patsy, now a grandmother with a nice home and a day job, no longer attending births, such as "You'd think by my age I'd have everything figured out, but I don't have a clue and I'm more confused than when I was thirty."  I concur.

I found to my surprise that Patsy's midwifery journey reminded me in many ways of my own. I was at the same time, learning about life, and discovering my midwife identity in a sort of mirror image journey.

Here's what I mean by a mirror image journey.

Patsy and I must be about the same age, and we gave birth to our babies at about the same time. I was living in Michigan in those formative years, the 1970s, in a little brick house with a basement, surrounded by tall oak trees that shed mountains of brown leaves each 'Fall'. I raked leaves in autumn, shovelled snow in the winter, planted spring gardens, and enjoyed home grown veges in the summer.

While Patsy learnt how to stay warm and well in an isolated primative log cabin, I, who had spent most of my life in the sub-tropics in Queensland, learnt how to live with central heating, and cook in a kitchen that had green carpet on the floor.

While Patsy and her companions had dropped out of education, I had already graduated as a midwife in my home country. Noel, my husband was a graduate student at Michigan State, working on the fascinating and previously unnoticed protective effect of colostrum in the newborn calf. I was absorbing scientific literature and knowledge as fast as I could, broadening my understanding of reproduction, and particularly the needs of mammalian newborns.

Like Patsy, I attended the local Lamaze birth preparation classes and learnt psychoprophylaxis and Lamaze breathing. Unlike Patsy, I did not discover homebirthing. I gave birth to my first three children in the local hospital, was moved in second stage to the delivery/operating room, positioned with legs in stirrups and hands held to boards by big pieces of velcro. I was told to "take a deep breath and push push push!"

While Patsy raised her children in a loosely knit 'family' of a commune, I was away from all my family, became a full-time mother, and was satisfied with that role. Apart from the help offered by a few neighbours and friends from our Church, I needed to be emotionally and physically self-sufficient.

While Patsy developed a sort of faith in the forces of nature, I continued in the Christian faith in which I had been nurtured.


My awakening in midwifery came later, in the early 1990s, when I thought that my four children no longer needed a parent to be at home for them all the time.

I was able to move without difficulty into homebirth, even though I had not given birth at home myself.  The knowledge that stood by me had been instilled in my mind over the years of my own childbearing, building on the foundation that I had learnt in my student days at the Royal Women's Hospital in Carlton.  The years of breastfeeding had given me insight into mother-baby bonding and nurture.  The years of parenting had given me an understanding of what it means to promote health, and work in harmony with natural processes.  The years of part time shift work, usually nights, in hospital maternity wards, had taught me that I wanted to be 'with woman' - that the 'one night stands' I was having in the hospitals were not optimal in any way.

Like a butterfly emerging from its quietness in the crysalis, I had metamorphosed, and came out of that space ready for action.

Enough from me for today.  Your comments are, as always, welcome.

ps Arms wide open is Hardcover, or eBook, 324 pages.  Publisher: Beacon Press. ISBN: 978-0807001387
http://www.patriciaharman.com

Monday, April 18, 2011

When birth is no longer normal

Midwives consider ourselves the guardians or keepers of normality in birth. We attend conferences and repeat slogans about keeping birth normal. We talk about sitting on our hands, about trusting the natural process, about protecting the woman's space so that she can give birth naturally and safely.

Our definition declares that our duty of care includes the promotion of normal birth.

Here is an excerpt from that definition of the midwife (ICM 2005):

"...
The midwife is recognised as a responsible and accountable professional who works in partnership with women to give the necessary support, care and advice during pregnancy, labour and the postpartum period, to conduct births on the midwife’s own responsibility and to provide care for the newborn and the infant. This care includes preventative measures, the promotion of normal birth, the detection of complications in mother and child, the accessing of medical care or other appropriate assistance and the carrying out of emergency measures.
..."

Australian midwives need to know this definition well. It has been adopted by our regulatory agency AHPRA, and the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Council, and is foundational to current midwifery education, codes and standards.

The big challenge for the midwife is to balance each aspect of our professional duty. Our desire to promote normal birth must not be allowed to over-ride our responsiblity to carry out preventative measures, or to detect complications in mother or child, access medical care and other appropriate assistance in a timely manner, and the carrying out of emergency measures.


I have reflected many times on what it means for a midwife to be a responsible and accountable professional. In recent submissions to government inquiries, I and other midwives have written about the processes by which midwives are required to give an account of what we do, and this is especially so when there is an adverse outcome. Our society has an expectation that professional care will be in the public interest; that the safety and wellbeing of mother and child are the primary concern of the midwife and any other person who provides professional maternity care.

A recent report by the Queensland Coroner on the death of a baby Samara Hoy has been distributed in midwifery circles.  It is a public document.  The Coroner's findings were critical of both midwifery and obstetric care (or the lack thereof) in this case. Reading the report has left me with many questions about the standard of care and culture of maternity services in that hospital.

If this woman had been planning homebirth, and her midwife had taken her to the local public hospital when meconium, fetal tachycardia, decelerations ... were observed, there would have been no question about continuous electronic fetal heart monitoring (EFM), or offering a theoretical set of options, one of which was waiting for nature to take its course.

That's the essence of midwifery: that if complications are detected, we have a process to follow, including "accessing of medical care or other appropriate assistance".

The tragedy in this story in my mind is that the woman was so alone. Although there was a person there with the role and title of midwife, there was no person with whom that mother had a partnership based on reciprocity and trust. There appears to have been no informed decision making by the woman. The decision by various midwives, and the collaborating doctor, to not even use the facilities available for checking the baby's response to the contractions suggests either a misplaced reliance on natural processes, or just plain incompetence. The physical findings of the Coroner of strangulation marks left by a tight umbilical cord around the baby's neck, and meconium aspiration, suggest that severe fetal distress would have been observable, particularly with EFM, for some time prior to the birth.

I can only surmise that the midwife was committed to a skewed idea of keeping birth normal, by sitting on her hands and keeping her head in the sand.

A young mother who has engaged me as her midwife for planned homebirth asked me under what circumstances would I think she would need a Caesarean birth.  I don't have an easy answer, but we chatted about how I know when birth is no longer normal, and what would happen in such a situation.

I know it's easy for me to be an armchair critic, but I have written this post with the hope that other midwives who read it will also reflect on what we do when birth is no longer normal.

Saturday, April 02, 2011

Midwifery knowledge

click to enlarge

One of my current projects is to lead the review of the Maternity Coalition INFOSHEETs - see the APMA blog for more detail. I also headed the previous working group which put together these information sheets in about 2006. Our aim was, and is, to provide reliable information that supports informed decision making for women and midwives who seek to promote normal physiological birthing, and to work in harmony with the natural processes in pregnancy, birth the perinatal period.

It's a big project, and the working group is asked to consider current evidence and practice, and check the information provided on the INFOSHEET. Recently we completed the first to be reviewed, A Baby's Transition From the Womb to the Outside World, (see jpeg file above) and are now working on The Third Stage of labour. Unfortunately I do not know how to link a .pdf file to this blog, so if you would like a copy of the revised document emailed, please send a request to me joy[at]aitex.com.au

A midwife commented to me that "what we need to say loud and clear is that we use Midwifery Knowledge which is very different and definitely not less than obstetric and surgical belief."

Yes, I (sort of) agree – but remember that ‘midwifery knowledge’ is not well defined, as is also the case with some 'medical' practices, or 'alternative health' knowledge. If our knowledge embraces truth, it's true regardless of whose it is. Midwifery knowledge should not belong to midwives only - it should be common knowledge.

If 'midwifery knowledge' is to be accepted as reliable it has to be well articulated and put out to scrutiny. I believe that’s what these infosheets are trying to do.

Management (or non-management) of the Third Stage (S3) and the time interval from birth to clamping of the umbilical cord are two examples of what I would call 'midwifery knowledge', compared with rituals that have been widely accepted by modern obstetrics and midwifery, without any evidence to support them.

I am excited to see changes in the mainstream maternity attitudes to time of clamping the cord, and protocols for active management of S3. This has been in response to evidence, just as the virtual mandating of active management of S3 in hospitals was in response to flawed evidence.

We must continually engage in critical review of all that we do. Many hospital ‘guidelines’ require [that’s an oxymoron I know] immediate clamping of the cord, and none of them that I have seen have a reference linked to it.

Watch the APMA blog in the coming weeks for developments in the revision of this INFOSHEET. This is all voluntary work, and it is put out in the public domain to encourage involvement of anyone who is interested.

Today’s Age newspaper has an article about a research program for which ethics approval is being sought for a cord blood trial, and the relationship between a baby receiving its own placental transfusion and cerebral palsy. There are many questions that this research, if well done, may begin to provide answers to. The proliferation of private facilities that collect and store cord blood, without any reliable evidence that the baby will benefit from it - and without any evidence that the baby has not been harmed by the withholding of that placental blood at the time of birth - is evidence that many parents have taken a punt on this issue.

Your comments are welcome.

Friday, March 25, 2011

The birth of Richie Jack

It is with a deep sense of respect and privilege that I share this birth story link with my readers. You are invited to go to Ashley's blog and read her story.


As the midwife I experience a parallel journey. Together we negotiate the often unpredictable and challenging terrain that leads to birth. Our partnership requires trust that goes both ways - she needs to feel able to trust me, and I her.

As I read Ash's birth story, I was reminded of my own emotional journey, and the series of decisions that were made. I felt challenged as time passed - of course I would have loved to see it all happen spontaneously.

Today I visited Ash and little Richie, and as we had a cup of tea together we chatted about the birth, and all that has transpired since then. As we packed the deflated birth pool into its box, and put it in the car boot, there was no sense of loss in our minds. The birth pool had not been used, and Ash had given birth in the hospital. The hospital was the right place for this birth; the best place.

What more could we ask?

Thursday, March 24, 2011

Midwives in Hungary

A report from Hungury, where homebirth midwives are being treated as criminals, prepared by Al Jazera


News [click here for link] has come that Agnes Gereb has been sentenced to two years in prison for malpractice, and banned from practicing both as an obstetrician and a midwife for five years.

Saturday, March 12, 2011

The villagemidwife e-book series


I am writing
To record my knowledge
To tell my stories
To teach others

I am a midwife. My words, thoughts and actions have been formed over many years and a unique set of experiences: the world into which I was born; the mother who bore me; the family that nurtured me; the towns and communities that have allowed me to be me, and this wide open land and its people.

I like to think that these are my thoughts, yet I know that much of what I say is my own filtering and organising of what I have absorbed from those around me. Although I am the speaker, I am not the source.

Midwifery belongs to women. The midwife is ‘with woman’, a companion for a distinct and definable childbearing event, in a special partnership. Midwifery does not belong to theorists, although the clear expression of the ‘with woman’ partnership by thinkers has helped set great value on this simple phrase.

Tuesday, March 08, 2011

Normal birth for a breech baby

From time to time a presentation becomes available via this wonderful www that is really worth sharing.

Today I would like to direct my readers to the blogs of two colleagues, midwives who are committed, as I am, to sharing the knowledge and skill of authentic midwifery. I would encourage you to follow these two links, then come back and read my comments. Please feel free to make any comment here, or on the other blogs too. (You know that comments are very much appreciated by bloggers.)

Lisa Barrett has written about the Mechanisms of unassisted normal breech birth, with a superb set of photos.

Carolyn Hastie has presented this You-Tube video, which is in Spanish, with her own comments.


Sunday, February 27, 2011

Patience


The matter that has occupied a great deal of my time and thinking space lately is the new world of maternity reform that centres on being 'eligible' for Medicare. A summary of the 'New Arrangements for Midwives' is at the MIPP blog.

My application for eligibility has been in the hands of the Nursing and Midwifery Board since early December 2010. I have had discussion with the Board's officer who has processed it, and my application was on the Board's agenda for this past Thursday. However, the meeting was adjourned unfinsihed, and my item was not discussed. It will be on the agenda for the reconvened meeting.

Saturday, February 19, 2011

A midwife's knitting


I have had knitting or crochet projects on the go, particularly in the cooler months, for as long as I can remember. My projects are not usually complicated. I lose interest in some and pull them apart so that the wool can be used for someting else. I have to be able to put it down and pick it up without losing my place. I'm not a particularly good knitter, not particularly fast.

There are shawls and rugs and hats and slippers and simple toys.

I was a little amused to read in a notice about the Womb-ecology Mid-Pacific conference coming up in Hawaii in 2012 that one of the workshops is ‘silent knitting’
“Of course the “silent knitting” session will be the historical symbol of the paradigm shift we are dreaming of after thousands of years of socialisation of childbirth, at a time when modern physiology is teaching us that one cannot positively help involuntary processes such as the birth process, but that some situations can inhibit them (neocortical activity and adrenaline release). Participants will be in an ideal situation to realise that avoiding the use of language is a way to reduce neocortical activity, and that a repetitive task like knitting is a way to reduce the level of stress hormones: a crucial step towards the rediscovery of authentic midwifery.”

Sunday, February 06, 2011

Pain

Beautiful Eve

Am I rushing in where angels fear to tread?

A recent post at the Science and Sensibility blog about Epidural Anaesthesia, written by well known Canadian family physician, Michael Klein MD, will be of interest to anyone who is interested in pain and childbearing. Dr Klein's paper is well referenced, and a reliable review of current medical knowledge about the topic.

The comments by readers reveal to me some of the myths and misunderstandings about pain and childbirth that I encounter from time to time. Comments quickly become defensive, assertive, and even aggressive in defending one camp or the other.

Thursday, February 03, 2011

Caring about professional conduct

The topic of this post is one that is unlikely to attract acolades for the writer. It's one of those aspects of professional practice that implies a risk to the recipients of care, and that sometimes difficult judgments need to be made in order to maintain a professional standard.

There are people in every walk of life who develop conditions that may impair their judgment or conduct, people whose thoughts and actions are adversely influenced by alcohol or other substances, and people who fail to meet the community's standard in terms of professional misconduct and abuse of their position of trust. There are also people whose actions as professionals are significantly different from accepted professional standards. While tolerance and acceptance of difference are values many of us hold dear, we must all take seriously our duty of care, and act to protect others at times when we observe conduct that is of concern.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Risk aversion

Midwives who attend women for homebirths have often been portrayed as having an affinity or fondness for risk, accepting and even encouraging situations that would not be considered suitable for midwife-led care in hospital.

Friday, January 14, 2011

Preparing for Medicare

Wonderful artwork by Poppy to brighten the page.
In early December I wrote about the fact that I had submitted my application to be noted as eligible for Medicare (see blog). I have been told that this application is being processed.
In preparation for submitting an application, all midwives are required to participate in a Professional Practice Review approved by the Board (NMBA). The review that I undertook is the Midwives in Private Practice Professional Practice Review ('MIPP PPR' for short) which had previously been submitted to the Board for approval. Having worked on the MIPP PPR since its introduction in 2002, I enjoyed updating it to meet the written requirements of the new Board, and then undertaking a practice review, and presenting my findings to an experienced and respected midwife colleague.

Saturday, January 08, 2011

Professional organisations and networks for midwives


Rally outside Julia Gillard's Werribee office 2009

In recent days I have had cause to reflect on the importance of various professional organisations and networks that are available for me as a midwife.  Here are a few:

Saturday, January 01, 2011

Plans for the new year

As the sun goes down on 1 January 2011 in our part of the world, others have just seen the New Year in.

I have noticed from the statistics function on this blog that a large number of the visitors to this blog are in the United States. G'day, folks! I am delighted to have you visit. I have wonderful memories of five winters in Michigan, and have attached a family pic, with me holding our first baby, that takes us back 37 years.
New Year 1974, at our home in Biscayne Way, Haslett Michigan


Twelve months ago, I and other Australian midwives were wondering if we would be able to practise legally, after 1 November. We are practising, and intend to continue. I won't say without change - anyone who is so set in their ways that they are not willing to change should not be practising. We must continue to change and grow in our understanding of birthing processes, while we adapt and work within the limitations of our own lives (such as ageing), and the law.

Wednesday, December 29, 2010

Homebirths 2008 in Victoria

For summary and comment go to the APMA blog.

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

"a goodly child"

Christmas greetings, as we celebrate the birth of the Child.

As the Christmas season approaches each year, it is usual in our family to not only send our greetings but to briefly summarise the highlights of the previous year.

I have always found this a challenge, wanting to say something worth hearing, without being tedious. The recipients of our letter include our families and close friends, with whom we communicate by phone, email, and in person as often as we can; and other friends, some of whom we have not seen for many years, and with whom we communicate only once a year.

I have been reflecting on the highs (and lows) of this year 2010, and my mind has returned consistently to the two new babies, James and Eve, who were born into our family in May, and who are thriving in mind and body. The wonder and beauty of new life is powerful enough to keep me going for as long as I have energy to think and write.

Like ripples in a pond, my thoughts have then moved to our precious grand-daughter Poppy, and beyond her to our own four children.  I have remembered my own mother, and the generations of mothers before her.

Grand-parents are allowed to dote, quite openly, on their grand-children. Parents are often more cautious. Parents carry the weight of many responsibilities, and often struggle to achieve what they consider basic, such as feeding, clothing, educating, teaching manners, and getting the children to bed on time.


In my musings about our grand-children, and our children, my thoughts moved to the story of a baby, in Exodus 2.
"The woman conceived and bore a son; and when she saw that he was a fine baby, she hid him three months." (verse 2)

Another version says he was "a goodly child". 

The story is well known.  After three months the mother made a little basket of papyrus, and plastered it with bitumen and pitch to make it water-proof, and set in in the shallow reedy part of the Nile river where the princess would come to wash.  She set her daughter Miriam as the onlooker, ready to offer practical assistance of a Hebrew 'wet nurse', the baby's own loving mother, when the princess also saw that he was a fine baby, and decided to keep him.  This decision saved the life of that baby boy.


When the birth of a child is welcomed by a mother who sees that this is "a goodly child", and that mother does all in her power to protect and nurture the child, even in the most adverse circumstances, there is hope for the future.  It was no miracle that the mother of the child saw that he was "a goodly child", and defied the government of the day in the most strategic way in looking after him.  The miracle was that the princess shared in the vision of "a goodly child".  She knew exactly what the mother intended, and she agreed with the mother's plan to save that child's life.

When a child is born there is a flooding of the love hormone, oxytocin, throughout the mother's body, in a way that she can only experience at such a time.  This outpouring continues with each touch, look, and suckle from the infant.  It is right for a mother to look at her child and see "a goodly child".  It is right and normal for a mother to use every strategy at her disposal to ensure the safety and nurture of that child, while maintaining the closeness of the exclusive mothering bond during the infant's first years.

I want to encourage every parent who reads this blog, to take a moment to look at your child, and see that she or he is wonderfully special, a child with great potential.  See that your child is "a goodly child".  Whatever the challenges you face in ensuring the safety and care of that child, so that she or he can grow to unhindered maturity emotionally and physically, keep your vision clear, and remember the mother whose child was wonderfully saved in infancy, and later became a great leader.

I also want to encourage midwives who read my writings to see each child as carrying immense and unmeasurable potential.  We midwives are the guardians of the next generation, protecting the mothers in their ability to not only give birth, but also to see their children for what they are.

May God's blessing be on you as we celebrate the birth of the Christ child.
Joy

Sunday, December 05, 2010

Loving

From time to time in this blog I attempt to write a personal letter to my readers. Many readers have never met me in person, and I don't know you. However, our common interest in midwifery and anything that touches on women's reproductive lives gives me the opportunity to use a broad range of topics in writing to you.


The wonder and beauty of human love shared by a woman and her man, are in my mind, founded on the creation story in Genesis 1. God created human kind “in our image, according to our likeness”; “in the image of God he created them, male and female he created them. God blessed them ... God saw everything that he had made, and indeed, it was very good.”

"Indeed, it was very good" the way our bodies, male and female, were created. The workings of the male-female creature, made wonderfully in God’s image and likeness, are indeed very good.

It [the way our bodies work together as woman and man] is very good whether we [intellectually] understand the processes or not. It is very good because it has been very good from the start, and we have a deep intuitive knowing that it is very good. 

This separation of intuitive ‘knowing’ from intellectual ‘learning’ fits with my understanding of normal, physiological childbirth and nurture of a baby. (I use the word ‘physiological’, to differentiate from normal meaning ‘usual’, which is often very far from the normal, natural process.)

Intuitive, or maieutic, knowing is influenced by the amazingly sensitive hormonal states within our bodies, and is not dependent on theoretical understanding of what's going on at the time. The intellectual ‘learning’, achieved through more didactic processes involving teachers/writers and students/readers, is a particularly human characteristic. Other creatures who share similar physiology do not seem to share our need, or capacity, to understand why, and how.

Although there are aspects of the whole loving – childbearing – child nurture spectrum that our minds are able to investigate and delve into, I believe that the unique opportunity that the creator has given us is that we can experience something that is VERY good best without seeking to manage, control, or even understand it.

I see this principle being worked out many times when a mother who has given birth to her child is transported into a relationship of deep love for that child.  Science calls it maternal instinct, and tells us that the primal parts of the mother’s brain are able to assert themselves, while the neocortex, or ‘new’ brain, is unstimulated.

That makes sense, and it reminds me that “indeed, it was very good.” The hormonal interactions of the normal loving – childbearing – nurture activities are “very good”. And when, as happens in these activities, there is a climax – a peak of the loving hormones, and we experience an altered state of consciousness with a huge rush of excitement, pain, wonder and amazement that we had not expected and that floods our being: indeed, that’s very good.

I don’t know if there is an ideal way for a couple to enjoy their oneness. I think it’s best not to seek that knowledge from an intellectual perspective. Each couple has the opportunity, in the privacy of their own relationship, to seek deeper and more enjoyable sexual intimacy. There is something reflecting the image and likeness of God in each of us that is, indeed, very good.

Thursday, December 02, 2010

Notation on the Register

I have now completed my application for 'notation' on the midwives register, as a midwife eligible for Medicare. My CV has been adapted to comply with the AHPRA standard, and copies of documents need to be certified as correct, also in compliance with the required standard.
This process has been a challenging one for me. A few of my trusted colleagues and friends wonder why I would even try to become 'eligible'. By accepting a terribly flawed process, am I not supporting our society's attempts to medicalise women's lives, and to give a veto power to the medical profession over midwifery and women's choice of physiological birth?
Readers who have followed this process will understand that the decisions midwives must make are complex.

I have come to a pragmatic point of acceptance:
... that the government has enacted a process for certain midwives to be eligible for Medicare.

The person who will benefit from my being eligible for Medicare is the woman, not me. The woman will be able to claim back some of the fee I charge - possibly one third for planned home births, and more if and when I am able to attend a woman privately for hospital birth.
I will seek to do all in my power to prevent this process from taking away a woman's freedom, or working under medical supervision in primary maternity care.

There are several hoops to jump through yet, and it may be a couple of months before I hear back from the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia if my application is successful.

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Update on Medicare

Bec and James
For an update on Midwives with Medicare provider numbers, go to the midwivesVictoria blog