Melbourne in mid-winter is grey and damp and cold. The tall concrete buildings block the weak, angled sunlight.
This week I have sat for two days in a tired meeting room in a city hotel that has passed its prime: not old enough to be interesting; not fresh enough to be attractive. The plate glass windows in the conference room revealed nothing more than the boarded up windows of a derelict multi-storey building on the other side of Little Collins Street.
The conference provided opportunities for comment on homebirth, and particularly homebirths that have gone wrong. Lawyers presented papers on topics such as 'Managing the Risks inherent in Women's Choice in Obstetric Care', and 'Practical Obstetric Risk Management: defending your care'. It sounded simple.
Human rights in the childbirth process were eloquently discussed by other lawyers who drew from both their knowledge of the law and their personal experience.
'Open Disclosure' was discussed by two speakers, and I concluded that, in order to 'defend' oneself against potential legal or disciplinary action, an adverse event in a hospital is met with what seems to me to be a charade called 'open disclosure' that is not very open, and that doesn't disclose much. Don't be too literal about the meaning of 'open' or the meaning of 'disclosure'. A curious conundrum!
A Coroner delivered, with barely an inflection in his voice, a keynote address on 'Lessons to be learned from the Home Birth Cases in Vic and SA.' In this presentation, seven cases were reviewed, the common thread being that they had been planned homebirths, with either a registered midwife or a previously registered midwife in attendance. When considering risk factors such as previous big babies, previous caesarean births, and a twin pregnancy, the conclusion was that most of these cases should not have been planned homebirths; that the midwife had a duty of care to transfer care to an obstetric unit.
In 6/7 cases, the baby deaths were declared by the Coroner to have been
potentially preventable. The Coroner does not attempt to apportion
blame, merely to discover the facts, and to make recommendations. The Coroner's filtering of the information presented at the inquest failed to notice any possible reason that a woman might have had for trying to avoid a medically managed birth; any mention of her desire to hold her baby to her breast within moments of birth; or even any recommendations that maternity hospitals provide pathways for women who want to have a known and trusted midwife providing continuity of care within the hospital.
I want to be perfectly clear here: I cannot speak for either the mothers or the midwives. I am merely an onlooker, and I have read the Coroner's findings that have been put in the public domain. I am also shocked at the tragedies that precipitated these cases into the Coroner's court.
The points made by those who spoke about women's rights were either ignored or not understood by those who spoke from the professional duty of care perspective. The fact is that pregnant women have personal autonomy; that decisions do not have to be approved by, or even understood by, those who attend for birth.
***
The presentation following that by the Coroner was from the Victorian Perinatal Data Collection Unit. I noted down a point that was briefly made, without any further comment, that, of the approximately 900 perinatal deaths in this State annually, 63% are found to have potentially avoidable factors.
The loss of a baby's life is, thankfully, uncommon in our world. Yet it is one of the most heart-wrenching experiences imaginable. Whether the death is linked to homebirth or not, everyone needs to take what lessons are available from the facts of the case. I ask myself, what lessons have I taken from these seven tragic cases?
***
I believe the huge challenge that lies ahead for midwives and the whole maternity world is to find a balance between providing advice and care that protects the wellbeing and safety of the mother and child, while at the same time respecting the woman's decisions and choices. This is not going to be easy. It is an ongoing process, and demands trust and commitment between the midwife-woman, and the midwife-obstetric/hospital system. The paternalistic dictatorial style of hospitals has, in many instances, demanded submission to hospital policies and processes. This needs to change. The misunderstanding of risk in maternity care, as was clearly demonstrated in the cases reviewed, will likely continue to open the door for self-educated, internet-researched women to make the choice of birthing without a midwife in attendance. This needs to change, to include intelligent dialogue and planning that is specific to the individual woman/pregnancy. The misunderstood partnership between woman and midwife, as was also clearly demonstrated in the cases reviewed, may from time to time place unreasonable weight on the woman's choice, and devalue the midwife's skill and knowledge. This also needs to change, enabling midwives to practise more autonomously and accountably.
Women who engage a midwife to attend them at home for birth, having an identified risk profile, such as a previous caesarean, a previous post partum haemorrhage, or multiparity, or any of the other features that are classified as risk - these women, and these midwives, need support rather than being driven underground. The midwife who is ready to go with her client to the hospital, and continue supporting the woman's informed decision-making process within the hospital, will accompany that woman to the best birth that she can have.
And, we only want the best.
Your comments are welcome.
ps - this link to the story of a maternal death is, sadly, what we will see more of if we don't maintain a midwifery profession that is 'with woman'.
This blog was initially focused on midwifery stories and critical comment on current issues. More recently I have begun commenting on life issues from the perspective of an older lady.
Saturday, June 22, 2013
Sunday, June 16, 2013
more about choice, decisions, and 'the birth you really wanted'
From time to time, as I read social media sites used by mothers, midwives, and others interested in the whole childbirth package, I come across messages such as:
"I was prevented by ... from having the birth I really wanted," or
"I'm so glad you got the birth you really wanted."
Women who feel physically and emotionally traumatised by experiences in previous births declare that they won't go near the hospital, because that's where and why it all happened the way it did.
More and more women are telling me that they are planning to give birth at home without professional support for various reasons - can't afford a midwife; no midwife or publicly funded homebirth program in the area; too 'high risk' for the midwives in the area ... This really concerns me - it's scary!
Homebirth has resurfaced in the local media recently, with an article by Sydney midwives, Karol Petrovska and Caroline Homer, Beyond the “homebirth horror” headlines: some wider questions for the health system (and media). This article was responding to a 'news' article on the mamamia blog, titled 'A hospital birth would have saved Kate's baby'.
The Coroner had identified internet-based research of risk as being central to the mother's choices and decisions in this instance
‘‘[This is] an example of the danger of untrained users utilising raw data or statistical information to support a premise as to risk, without knowledge and understanding of the complex myriad of factors relevant to the risk’’.[report]
The Coroner also found that delay in transferring care from home to hospital, after it should have been apparent to the midwives that Kate's baby was in distress, contributed to the death.
Midwives hold to a theory of 'partnership' with each woman in our care. The midwife-woman partnership has been incorporated into the ICM International Definition of the Midwife.
This partnership, when correctly applied, places the woman at the centre of all decisions, with the intention of protecting the wellbeing and safety of mother and child.
Today I would like to briefly comment on the midwife-woman partnership, especially as it applies to choice, decisions, and achieving 'the birth you really wanted'.
Independent midwives, employed directly by women for birth in their own home, are in a privileged position because we are able to apply midwifery skill, knowledge and expertise directly without being hampered by the levels of bureaucracy and policy and protocol that exist in hospitals. Women who are low risk and who plan to give birth at home with a midwife in attendance are in the most optimal maternity care situation that exists today. A large study (de Jonge et al 2013) comparing maternal outcomes from (low risk) homebirths with a comparable group of (low risk) women giving birth in hospitals in the Netherlands concluded that:
There is no calculation table that lists risk factors against chance of having an uncomplicated vaginal birth - and if there were, I doubt that it would be of any use. The current 'odds' for serious adverse complications (such as death of a baby, or serious maternal haemorrhage from uterine rupture) in vbac is estimated at 1:2000. [for more on safety of vbac, click here] There is no comparable statistical estimate that ordinary people face in daily living. People who bet on horse races may have some understanding. 1:2000 seems remote, and meaningless.
A more useful guidance would be to define at what point in time does actual risk, rather than theoretical risk, escalate. This appears to me to be a question that was not thoroughly explored in the tragic case referenced at the beginning of this post. This clinical judgment is within the scope of a midwife's practice. Spontaneous, unassisted birth becomes less safe if there is anything that indicates compromise of the mother or the fetus: complications of pregnancy, including raised blood pressure or impaired glucose tolerance; prolonged pregnancy; antepartum haemorrhage. Complications of labour including poor progress over time; and fetal heart rate decelerations or other abnormalities.
When 'the birth I really wanted' focuses on place of birth, or even on the process of birth, a significant number of mothers are going to be disappointed. A midwife cannot become so committed to homebirth, or natural birth, that she forgets to keep a keen, critical eye on what is actually happening. There are a couple of significant hurdles that a woman needs to get over before the spontaneous, unmedicated homebirth can even be considered. These are:
As it happens, there is no safer way for most babies to be born, than for the mother to do it herself - spontaneously - irrespective of place. Not with herbal stimulants or acupuncture or coaching or hypno/calm birth education or pelvic manipulation or olive oil being rubbed into the perineum, or the best midwife in town. Spontaneous is from within. As labour progresses, a mother's capacity to judge progress and safety decreases, as her calculating, educated mind closes down to permit intuitive activity from deeper brain structures. As this altered state of consciousness becomes strong, her midwife maintains a skilled, watchful vigil. A mother cannot do this for herself.
The midwife's role is clear: if the mother and baby are coping well with spontaneous labour, no interruption or interference is permitted. On the other hand, if warning signs are present, the midwife's ongoing clinical judgment and assessment throughout the birthing process protect the interests of her clients, both mother and baby.
You might have a birth plan for 'the birth I really want'. Please check that birth plan, and check with your midwife, to ensure clear decision points. While you are able to spontaneously progress through labour and birth, the physiological process is magnificent. But, if there is a valid reason to interrupt the natural process, be ready to get the best birth possible, using the best and most timely intervention that is accessible at the time.
'The birth I really wanted' is above all, one that protects my baby and myself.
Thankyou for your comments.
"I was prevented by ... from having the birth I really wanted," or
"I'm so glad you got the birth you really wanted."
Women who feel physically and emotionally traumatised by experiences in previous births declare that they won't go near the hospital, because that's where and why it all happened the way it did.
More and more women are telling me that they are planning to give birth at home without professional support for various reasons - can't afford a midwife; no midwife or publicly funded homebirth program in the area; too 'high risk' for the midwives in the area ... This really concerns me - it's scary!
Homebirth has resurfaced in the local media recently, with an article by Sydney midwives, Karol Petrovska and Caroline Homer, Beyond the “homebirth horror” headlines: some wider questions for the health system (and media). This article was responding to a 'news' article on the mamamia blog, titled 'A hospital birth would have saved Kate's baby'.
The Coroner had identified internet-based research of risk as being central to the mother's choices and decisions in this instance
‘‘[This is] an example of the danger of untrained users utilising raw data or statistical information to support a premise as to risk, without knowledge and understanding of the complex myriad of factors relevant to the risk’’.[report]
The Coroner also found that delay in transferring care from home to hospital, after it should have been apparent to the midwives that Kate's baby was in distress, contributed to the death.
Midwives hold to a theory of 'partnership' with each woman in our care. The midwife-woman partnership has been incorporated into the ICM International Definition of the Midwife.
This partnership, when correctly applied, places the woman at the centre of all decisions, with the intention of protecting the wellbeing and safety of mother and child.
Today I would like to briefly comment on the midwife-woman partnership, especially as it applies to choice, decisions, and achieving 'the birth you really wanted'.
Independent midwives, employed directly by women for birth in their own home, are in a privileged position because we are able to apply midwifery skill, knowledge and expertise directly without being hampered by the levels of bureaucracy and policy and protocol that exist in hospitals. Women who are low risk and who plan to give birth at home with a midwife in attendance are in the most optimal maternity care situation that exists today. A large study (de Jonge et al 2013) comparing maternal outcomes from (low risk) homebirths with a comparable group of (low risk) women giving birth in hospitals in the Netherlands concluded that:
"Low risk women in primary care at the onset of labour with planned home birth had lower rates of severe acute maternal morbidity, postpartum haemorrhage, and manual removal of placenta than those with planned hospital birth. For parous women these differences were statistically significant. Absolute risks were small in both groups. There was no evidence that planned home birth among low risk women leads to an increased risk of severe adverse maternal outcomes in a maternity care system with well trained midwives and a good referral and transportation system."Independent midwives practising in Australia are often asked to attend births that are not in the low risk category. Women who are older, fatter, who have had a lot of children, or caesarean births, or who have been traumatised in previous births often seek a midwife who will plan homebirth with them, particularly those who want to avoid the hospital.
There is no calculation table that lists risk factors against chance of having an uncomplicated vaginal birth - and if there were, I doubt that it would be of any use. The current 'odds' for serious adverse complications (such as death of a baby, or serious maternal haemorrhage from uterine rupture) in vbac is estimated at 1:2000. [for more on safety of vbac, click here] There is no comparable statistical estimate that ordinary people face in daily living. People who bet on horse races may have some understanding. 1:2000 seems remote, and meaningless.
A more useful guidance would be to define at what point in time does actual risk, rather than theoretical risk, escalate. This appears to me to be a question that was not thoroughly explored in the tragic case referenced at the beginning of this post. This clinical judgment is within the scope of a midwife's practice. Spontaneous, unassisted birth becomes less safe if there is anything that indicates compromise of the mother or the fetus: complications of pregnancy, including raised blood pressure or impaired glucose tolerance; prolonged pregnancy; antepartum haemorrhage. Complications of labour including poor progress over time; and fetal heart rate decelerations or other abnormalities.
When 'the birth I really wanted' focuses on place of birth, or even on the process of birth, a significant number of mothers are going to be disappointed. A midwife cannot become so committed to homebirth, or natural birth, that she forgets to keep a keen, critical eye on what is actually happening. There are a couple of significant hurdles that a woman needs to get over before the spontaneous, unmedicated homebirth can even be considered. These are:
- spontaneous onset of labour, and
- spontaneous progress in labour - to the point where natural expulsive forces can be applied.
As it happens, there is no safer way for most babies to be born, than for the mother to do it herself - spontaneously - irrespective of place. Not with herbal stimulants or acupuncture or coaching or hypno/calm birth education or pelvic manipulation or olive oil being rubbed into the perineum, or the best midwife in town. Spontaneous is from within. As labour progresses, a mother's capacity to judge progress and safety decreases, as her calculating, educated mind closes down to permit intuitive activity from deeper brain structures. As this altered state of consciousness becomes strong, her midwife maintains a skilled, watchful vigil. A mother cannot do this for herself.
The midwife's role is clear: if the mother and baby are coping well with spontaneous labour, no interruption or interference is permitted. On the other hand, if warning signs are present, the midwife's ongoing clinical judgment and assessment throughout the birthing process protect the interests of her clients, both mother and baby.
You might have a birth plan for 'the birth I really want'. Please check that birth plan, and check with your midwife, to ensure clear decision points. While you are able to spontaneously progress through labour and birth, the physiological process is magnificent. But, if there is a valid reason to interrupt the natural process, be ready to get the best birth possible, using the best and most timely intervention that is accessible at the time.
'The birth I really wanted' is above all, one that protects my baby and myself.
Thankyou for your comments.
Labels:
birth plan,
caesarean,
decision,
drugs,
private midwifery practice,
spontaneous birth,
VBAC
Saturday, June 01, 2013
Midwives and Medicare
For the past 2+ years I have been able to give clients Medicare rebates for antenatal and postnatal midwifery services. I am looking forward to having a prescriber number in the near future. This is part of the government's reform measure, More Choice for Women - Expanding Medicare Support for Midwives, introduced in November 2010.
The basic requirement that I must fulfill before a client can claim a Medicare rebate is that there is a collaborative arrangement in place: a letter or statement, signed by a suitable doctor. As I have no 'agreement' to meet this need, I must seek out an arrangement for each woman.
There are a couple of doctors who have 'collaborated' with me on more than one occasion. Most of the time it's a one-off. Most of my clients live within a 1-hour drive radius of my home. That's a huge metropolitan area, and some out in nearby towns. In that area there are thousands of doctors. Very few have met me. Some have refused to collaborate, saying that they would thereby be liable for anything I did.
Several months ago a woman who has had three previous uncomplicated births in hospital contacted me. She wants to have her next baby at home. I explained Medicare and collaboration, and emailed a letter describing the need for a collaborative arrangement with a doctor, to her. She took the letter to her local doctor. In her own words,
With this woman's permission, I forwarded her letter to the Health Minister, Hon Tan Plibersek, MP. The letter I have received from the Minister's office, in reply, gives me hope that the wrinkles may be ironed out.
Excerpts from the Minister's letter, dated 27 May 2013:
My comment:
A letter like this to an ordinary inquirer like me does not give any new information. However, I feel encouraged by the tone of the latter part of the letter.
Specifically:
Your comments are welcome
The basic requirement that I must fulfill before a client can claim a Medicare rebate is that there is a collaborative arrangement in place: a letter or statement, signed by a suitable doctor. As I have no 'agreement' to meet this need, I must seek out an arrangement for each woman.
There are a couple of doctors who have 'collaborated' with me on more than one occasion. Most of the time it's a one-off. Most of my clients live within a 1-hour drive radius of my home. That's a huge metropolitan area, and some out in nearby towns. In that area there are thousands of doctors. Very few have met me. Some have refused to collaborate, saying that they would thereby be liable for anything I did.
Several months ago a woman who has had three previous uncomplicated births in hospital contacted me. She wants to have her next baby at home. I explained Medicare and collaboration, and emailed a letter describing the need for a collaborative arrangement with a doctor, to her. She took the letter to her local doctor. In her own words,
I
am just writing to advise you of the trouble that I am having getting a GP to
write a referral to your services.
After
contracting you to get a letter for the referring doctor, I went to my local GP
for confirmation of my pregnancy. They were happy to send me for tests and
ultrasounds but when I explained that I didn't want to birth my fourth child in
a hospital, but rather have midwifery care and plan a homebirth I was met with
an almost hostile response. This GP who had seen me throughout 2 of my previous
pregnancys pointed out that he would not write me a referral due to the use of
the word "collaborative" . He failed to understand where his duty of
care ended and the midwife's began. I tried to explain that I didn't need to
see him throughout the pregnancy and that I only needed initial blood tests and
this letter but he would not listen. He continued to explain that he would not
put his reputation on the line for the sake of my Medicare rebate!
Feeling
disheartened I searched for a doctor who had a similar outlook on the way birth
should be. I felt positive that this woman would give me the referral I needed.
This
time the doctor endorsed homebirth, was happy for me to see a private midwife
and ordered the appropriate tests to be sent to my chosen care provider but
once more would not write the letter. When I asked for an explanation once
again there was talk of scaremongering from insurance companies who had advised
her that if she wrote this letter and something went wrong at the birth, even
if she was 200ks away she would be liable.
I
find it extremely frustrating and disheartening that in order to get the birth
that is right for me and my family, I am being financially penalised because my
doctors of choice don't fully understand what is required of them.
With this woman's permission, I forwarded her letter to the Health Minister, Hon Tan Plibersek, MP. The letter I have received from the Minister's office, in reply, gives me hope that the wrinkles may be ironed out.
Excerpts from the Minister's letter, dated 27 May 2013:
The More Choice for Women - Expanding Medicare Support for Midwives, introduced on 1 November 2010, expanded the Medicare arrangements to include midwifery care. This was in recognition that women should have a range of birthing options available to them and be supported in their choice of practitioner.
Recognising midwives as primary maternity care providers under Medicare was also intended to assist in improving service delivery by enabling better use of the existing workforce ...
...
Since the measure was introduced, midwives have reported ongoing difficulties with establishing collaborative arrangements with individual medical practitioners. This has hindered their ability to provide services under Medicare.
In recognition of this, at the Standing Committee on Health (SCoH) meeting of 10 August 2012, the Minister for Health ... agreed to vary the legislation on collaborative arrangements, to enable agreements between midwives and hospitals and health services.
The Department is currently in discussion with the medical, midwifery and consumer groups to discuss the detail of the proposed changes.
The Minister recognises that the lack of hospital clinical privileging and admitting and practice rights is a fundamental issue for midwives. This prevents privately practising eligible midwives from working to their full scope of practice, undermines continuity of care and reduces choice for women.
As such, the Minister has asked Health Ministers to finalise consistent approaches to credentialing for midwives in public hospitals in line with States' and Territories' commitments under the Maternity Services Plan.
The Minister is committed to supporting increased participation by eligible midwives in the Medicare arrangements and to the proposed changes to the collaborative arrangement requirements that would facilitate this.
Thankyou for raising this important issue. I trust this information is of assistance to you.
Yours sincerely
[&c]
My comment:
A letter like this to an ordinary inquirer like me does not give any new information. However, I feel encouraged by the tone of the latter part of the letter.
Specifically:
- that midwives need practising rights in public hospitals
- that the Minister has put pressure on the State and Territory Health Ministers, to get a move on
- that public hospitals will be expected to support collaborative arrangements with midwives
- that the Minister is committed to this reform measure.
- the inequity of signed collaborative arrangements, in that the midwife is required to obtain the arrangement, but no doctor is obliged to agree or to sign anything. The loser, of course, is the woman. AND the midwife looks pretty useless.
- the lengthy delays (such as since SCoH in August 2012) in making even the promised changes to the Collaboration Determination
- the obstruction by public hospitals throughout the country, with the exception of a few in S-E Qld, to any progress on practising rights for midwives
- with the above point in mind, surely it's unlikely that these hospitals will agree to collaborate with midwives, even after the legislation has been varied as promised
- and finally, with an election, and probably a change of government in September, will we see ongoing support for More Choice for Women - Expanding Medicare Support for Midwives?
Your comments are welcome
Friday, May 17, 2013
Baby Bonus gone
The federal treasurer's announcement in the Budget 2013 that there is to be no Baby Bonus from early 2014 is, in my opinion, a sad legacy of the present government, and an equally lamentable commentary on the opposition's lack of support for those who need it most.
Mothers who stay at home with their young children, particularly in the pre-school years; mothers who do not benefit from paid parental leave because they do not have employment out of the home; families who live on one income - these are the ones who will miss the baby bonus most. And, as it happens, many in this sub-group of modern Australian communities are the ones who also value wellness and protection of health in pregnancy, birth, and nurture of their babies - and who employ a midwife privately. Many mothers have 'afforded' homebirth, knowing that they will be entitled to the baby bonus. So, in that sense, I must declare that my interest in the baby bonus is, in part, linked to my need to earn a living as a midwife.
I don't have time thismorning to write any more, but will get to it as soon as I can, and add to this post. Any comments from readers will be appreciated, either in the comments section here, or by email.
later...
Responses received in 4 our so hours since I wrote include:
Cancelling the baby bonus demonstrates ...
A quick review of media around the scrapping of the baby bonus informs me that there will be an end to the current baby boom, that teenage pregnancies will be discouraged, and that families will no longer have 'one for the country', as proposed by Peter Costello in 2004. The consensus amongst thinking people seems to be that the baby bonus is better relegated to the wastebin of bad economic management.
Here's a story. Once upon a time ...
I see the cancellation of the Baby Bonus as the rich man taking from those who are weakest and least able to defend their own interests in the political arena.
When (then Treasurer) Peter Costello introduced the Baby Bonus reform legislation in 2002, he stated that:
![]() |
| It sometimes takes a cartoon to speak truthfully about political situations. Thanks, Australian. |
Mothers who stay at home with their young children, particularly in the pre-school years; mothers who do not benefit from paid parental leave because they do not have employment out of the home; families who live on one income - these are the ones who will miss the baby bonus most. And, as it happens, many in this sub-group of modern Australian communities are the ones who also value wellness and protection of health in pregnancy, birth, and nurture of their babies - and who employ a midwife privately. Many mothers have 'afforded' homebirth, knowing that they will be entitled to the baby bonus. So, in that sense, I must declare that my interest in the baby bonus is, in part, linked to my need to earn a living as a midwife.
I don't have time thismorning to write any more, but will get to it as soon as I can, and add to this post. Any comments from readers will be appreciated, either in the comments section here, or by email.
later...
Responses received in 4 our so hours since I wrote include:
Cancelling the baby bonus demonstrates ...
"undervaluing of the role of a parent"Yes, the current social pressure to have children of all ages cared for by specially designated child care businesses does ignore the very real intuitive and personal roles of parents in caring for, guiding, and teaching their own children.
"full time parenting is not recognised as gainful or important. ... the role of a stay at home mum has been labelled 'for the chronically unambitious'."Outrageous!
"I think this really will have an impact of breastfeeding and extended breastfeeding rates."No doubt!
...
Then, there are those who have seen what they consider to be abuse of the government's over-generous middle class welfare, new parents who have boasted of purchasing the flat screen TV, state of the art coffee machine, new sofa or a trip to Bali.
or, as a midwife notes,
Yes, any social welfare scheme can be abused. We Australians have many supports provided by government at the time when our babies are being born and nurtured, including family tax benefit, parenting payment, as well as the child care benefit and child care rebate for children in approved care facilities. For more detail, click here."the women in [low socio-economic area/suburb] who come back and have a new baby each year, and can't wait to get the Centrelink forms filled out so that they can get their payments."
A quick review of media around the scrapping of the baby bonus informs me that there will be an end to the current baby boom, that teenage pregnancies will be discouraged, and that families will no longer have 'one for the country', as proposed by Peter Costello in 2004. The consensus amongst thinking people seems to be that the baby bonus is better relegated to the wastebin of bad economic management.
Here's a story. Once upon a time ...
There were two men in a certain city. One was very rich, and he had properties and flocks and herds and many possessions. The other was very poor, and lived near the rich man. He owned just one ewe lamb, which the poor man had bought. The poor man and his family loved that lamb, and it ate their food, and drank from the same cup, and slept in the poor man's arms. Now one day a traveler arrived at the rich man's house, and he invited the traveler to stay for dinner. The rich man did not take a lamb from his own flock, but in stead took the lamb from the poor man, killed it and had it prepared for his meal.[This story is based on the one in 2 Samuel 12.]
I see the cancellation of the Baby Bonus as the rich man taking from those who are weakest and least able to defend their own interests in the political arena.
When (then Treasurer) Peter Costello introduced the Baby Bonus reform legislation in 2002, he stated that:
"The Baby Bonus recognises that one of the hardest times for families, financially, follows the birth of a first child. A family could lose one of its two incomes for a period of time as the mother, or father, gives up or reduces paid employment to care for the child." [click here for more]The need for support when one parent gives up or reduces paid employment to care for a child is an ongoing need. By all means, the provision of the baby bonus should be refined and managed in a way that minimises abuse. In the current financial situation, I believe it would have been prudent for the opposition to hold to the long-term support of this program, rather than supporting the government's plan to use the ewe lamb owned by the poor man to feed the rich man's guest.
Labels:
baby bonus,
homebirth,
private midwifery practice
Wednesday, May 15, 2013
physical midwifery
Today I am pondering the physical demands of my sort of midwifery, at the primary maternity care end of the professional spectrum. This means that I, the midwife am committed to being with woman, regardless of time or place.
It means that I accept phone calls at any hour, and that I am prepared to get in my car and go to a woman who calls me.
It means that I lug my equipment - the case with supplies; the oxygen cylinder; the bag and mask; the baby scales ... up flights or stairs, or wherever they need to be.
It means that I have no idea when I will be home again; that I have to organise my private life so that my absences are manageable within my family.
It means that I need strategies for driving home safely after a long night on the job, so that I don't fall asleep at the wheel.
It means that when my ageing body complains, with aches and pains in shoulder, or foot, or wherever, I am prepared to carefully consider my capacity to continue in my profession.
But, you might say, it's the birthing woman who is physical. She's the only one who can give birth. She's the only one who can breastfeed and nurture and love that baby as mother.
Yes. Birthing is the essence of phyiscality.
When I studied midwifery we were taught about the 3 'p's:
You might think that being a midwife is a matter of sitting on your hands, or better still, knitting.
When I was working as a midwife in a hospital the physical demands of my job included traversing long corridors to check on the women in my care, or to answer the 'buzzer'. It included manual lifting of women from theatre trolleys to beds, or positioning women who couldn't move themselves. It included leaning across the bed to assist babies with breastfeeding, or to extract minute amounts of liquid gold colostrum from breasts of new mothers.
Today my office is in my home, and I spend much of my time here. I am glad I don't have the physical demands of mainstream hospital midwifery to deal with. I'm glad I don't need to work night shifts, although some of the best times for being with woman in hospital are in the wee hours.
I'm glad I have strength sufficient for the task.
It means that I accept phone calls at any hour, and that I am prepared to get in my car and go to a woman who calls me.
It means that I lug my equipment - the case with supplies; the oxygen cylinder; the bag and mask; the baby scales ... up flights or stairs, or wherever they need to be.
It means that I have no idea when I will be home again; that I have to organise my private life so that my absences are manageable within my family.
It means that I need strategies for driving home safely after a long night on the job, so that I don't fall asleep at the wheel.
It means that when my ageing body complains, with aches and pains in shoulder, or foot, or wherever, I am prepared to carefully consider my capacity to continue in my profession.
But, you might say, it's the birthing woman who is physical. She's the only one who can give birth. She's the only one who can breastfeed and nurture and love that baby as mother.
Yes. Birthing is the essence of phyiscality.
When I studied midwifery we were taught about the 3 'p's:
- the passage (birth canal)
- the power (contractions of uterus and mother's expulsive efforts)
- the passenger (the baby)
You might think that being a midwife is a matter of sitting on your hands, or better still, knitting.
When I was working as a midwife in a hospital the physical demands of my job included traversing long corridors to check on the women in my care, or to answer the 'buzzer'. It included manual lifting of women from theatre trolleys to beds, or positioning women who couldn't move themselves. It included leaning across the bed to assist babies with breastfeeding, or to extract minute amounts of liquid gold colostrum from breasts of new mothers.
Today my office is in my home, and I spend much of my time here. I am glad I don't have the physical demands of mainstream hospital midwifery to deal with. I'm glad I don't need to work night shifts, although some of the best times for being with woman in hospital are in the wee hours.
I'm glad I have strength sufficient for the task.
Saturday, May 04, 2013
A joey in the pouch
| Baby Lucinda in the pouch |
| Baby Amelie in the bilum - a string bag from Papua New Guinea - not too sure if it's a good idea |
![]() |
| Baby Mizz on Noel's back |
| even Granny can do it! |
Thursday, April 25, 2013
Making the bed
I drove through crisp Autumn air, under blue sky, to visit the mother and her baby boy who was just 24 hours old.
Within minutes of laying eyes on them, and without touching either, I was satisfied that all was as it should be. With early morning light filtering onto the bed, I noticed that the baby was sleeping quietly in his mother's arms; that his skin was a healthy pink; that his mother had a confident, oxytocin-induced smile. A few questions confirmed my assessment: mother's blood loss was minimal; she was eating and drinking well; passing urine without difficulty; she had slept a little, and her baby was eagerly taking the breast.
It's difficult to describe the deep thankfulness that I feel as I witness the normality of birth. Much of the preparation and discussion prior to the birth focus on what would happen if complications or difficulties arise in labour, or if the baby's condition at birth is not good. The equipment and supplies I bring to the birth require skill and competence in assessment, resuscitation, and midwifery management of sometimes unpredictable, rare events.
Although the assessment was made with the confidence that comes from years of professional learning, at this postnatal visit I did not need to take any professional action. I asked the mother if she had had breakfast yet, would she like a cup of tea? Yes. So the midwifery student went to the kitchen to prepare it. We reflected on the exhaustion a mother feels after even an 'uneventful' spontaneous birth. We laughed at the though that the father is often more spent! We pondered the help given by the warm water in the birth pool; that the softness of the pool's inflated sides gave the mother a lovely soft surface upon which to drape her upper body in the most demanding part of the labour. We chatted about the responses of the baby's brother and sister, building up a set of unique and very personal memories of this unique and very personal event.
I had noticed a small splatter of blood on the bed sheet. "Would you like us to make the bed for you, with clean sheets?" I asked.
And while mother ate her toast and drank the hot herbal brew, we changed the sheets.
Making beds happens each morning in hospital, and it's not something that I would write about in a midwifery context. Yet as we went away from this beautiful homeborn baby and his beautiful mother, I thought that making the bed was the main professional act that we had accomplished in that visit.
Within minutes of laying eyes on them, and without touching either, I was satisfied that all was as it should be. With early morning light filtering onto the bed, I noticed that the baby was sleeping quietly in his mother's arms; that his skin was a healthy pink; that his mother had a confident, oxytocin-induced smile. A few questions confirmed my assessment: mother's blood loss was minimal; she was eating and drinking well; passing urine without difficulty; she had slept a little, and her baby was eagerly taking the breast.
It's difficult to describe the deep thankfulness that I feel as I witness the normality of birth. Much of the preparation and discussion prior to the birth focus on what would happen if complications or difficulties arise in labour, or if the baby's condition at birth is not good. The equipment and supplies I bring to the birth require skill and competence in assessment, resuscitation, and midwifery management of sometimes unpredictable, rare events.
Although the assessment was made with the confidence that comes from years of professional learning, at this postnatal visit I did not need to take any professional action. I asked the mother if she had had breakfast yet, would she like a cup of tea? Yes. So the midwifery student went to the kitchen to prepare it. We reflected on the exhaustion a mother feels after even an 'uneventful' spontaneous birth. We laughed at the though that the father is often more spent! We pondered the help given by the warm water in the birth pool; that the softness of the pool's inflated sides gave the mother a lovely soft surface upon which to drape her upper body in the most demanding part of the labour. We chatted about the responses of the baby's brother and sister, building up a set of unique and very personal memories of this unique and very personal event.
I had noticed a small splatter of blood on the bed sheet. "Would you like us to make the bed for you, with clean sheets?" I asked.
And while mother ate her toast and drank the hot herbal brew, we changed the sheets.
Making beds happens each morning in hospital, and it's not something that I would write about in a midwifery context. Yet as we went away from this beautiful homeborn baby and his beautiful mother, I thought that making the bed was the main professional act that we had accomplished in that visit.
Sunday, April 21, 2013
Informed decision making
As I take a few moments to reflect on the past couple of weeks, I am trying to pull together the issues in the world of maternity, and highlight anything that needs critical comment from yours truly.
The AMA's new Position Statement on Maternal Decision-Making is worth focusing on for a few moments. My initial comments are at the MidwivesVictoria blog.
The topic of 'decision-making' in situations of known risk - particularly breech and twin births - is being discussed constantly by mothers, via social media. One group, linked to BBANZ, that I belong to, often has messages from women who are torn between options that appear to be poles apart - the elective caesarean, or the unpredictable, un-knowable journey of spontaneous natural birth. Another option comes up from time to time, especially for women who have financial reserves + private health insurance and can access a private maternity hospital and a sympathetic obstetrician (that's a big IF), that the doctor sets out the 'rules'.
"OK, here's the plan. You come to hospital as soon as your labour starts and ..."
These few obstetricians, well known for pushing boundaries, set down what they believe is the safest course of action in the given situation. They (understandably) want good outcomes, as do the women in their care. They are able to achieve good outcomes if they recognise the time when it is best to depart from the spontaneous natural process, and take decisive action without delay. This may mean delivering a baby with forceps or ventouse, or moving to the operating theatre for caesarean surgery. The women understand the rules, as they have been discussed, and are expected to submit to them.
In many cases, this is an acceptable, and successful exchange. Yet it is medical dominance, with a touch of class, Melbourne style.
When the doctor enunciates the plan, and receives a compliant nod from the woman, there is a big exchange of trust. There is not likely to be any subsequent *informed* decision-making by the woman, because she has entered a 'plan' with her doctor.
This phenomenon disturbs me as much as any other form of medical dominance, whether it is carried out in a private arrangement, or in the less refined tactics that we often experience in public hospitals. The woman's ability to bear and nurture her child is a basic ability that requires huge respect. I would like to suggest that the AMA position on maternal decision-making is not worth the paper it is written on, unless the protection of the woman's own natural processes in childbearing, including spontaneous onset of labour, giving birth, and breastfeeding, are held in high priority, and not by-passed without a valid reason.
| no explanation required! |
The AMA's new Position Statement on Maternal Decision-Making is worth focusing on for a few moments. My initial comments are at the MidwivesVictoria blog.
The topic of 'decision-making' in situations of known risk - particularly breech and twin births - is being discussed constantly by mothers, via social media. One group, linked to BBANZ, that I belong to, often has messages from women who are torn between options that appear to be poles apart - the elective caesarean, or the unpredictable, un-knowable journey of spontaneous natural birth. Another option comes up from time to time, especially for women who have financial reserves + private health insurance and can access a private maternity hospital and a sympathetic obstetrician (that's a big IF), that the doctor sets out the 'rules'.
"OK, here's the plan. You come to hospital as soon as your labour starts and ..."
These few obstetricians, well known for pushing boundaries, set down what they believe is the safest course of action in the given situation. They (understandably) want good outcomes, as do the women in their care. They are able to achieve good outcomes if they recognise the time when it is best to depart from the spontaneous natural process, and take decisive action without delay. This may mean delivering a baby with forceps or ventouse, or moving to the operating theatre for caesarean surgery. The women understand the rules, as they have been discussed, and are expected to submit to them.
In many cases, this is an acceptable, and successful exchange. Yet it is medical dominance, with a touch of class, Melbourne style.
When the doctor enunciates the plan, and receives a compliant nod from the woman, there is a big exchange of trust. There is not likely to be any subsequent *informed* decision-making by the woman, because she has entered a 'plan' with her doctor.
This phenomenon disturbs me as much as any other form of medical dominance, whether it is carried out in a private arrangement, or in the less refined tactics that we often experience in public hospitals. The woman's ability to bear and nurture her child is a basic ability that requires huge respect. I would like to suggest that the AMA position on maternal decision-making is not worth the paper it is written on, unless the protection of the woman's own natural processes in childbearing, including spontaneous onset of labour, giving birth, and breastfeeding, are held in high priority, and not by-passed without a valid reason.
Saturday, April 06, 2013
Welcoming the newest member of the family
![]() |
| Thanks to Bec and Al for this picture |
In the past few weeks, in writing this blog, I have delved into personal memories and thoughts, preparing for and anticipating a particular birth. I expect this fact has been clear to many of my readers; many being women with whom I have shared that deep and wonderous journey. Although I usually write in an impersonal way of 'the woman' and 'the midwife', so much of my knowledge of midwifery is inextricably linked to my own experiences in childbearing and mothering - intensely personal. In many ways, I am the woman; I am the midwife; I am even the child.
Tonight as I sit at my computer, thinking of how I can express the wonder that is welling up in my heart, I hear the brief small cry of the wee one in another room of our home. I know she will soon be transported back into that milky dream world, her little body being nourished by the abundant supply that is freely given.
I treasure the memory of the first view of her beautiful face, and the ecstatic glow on her mother's face, as we three - mother, child, and midwife - three generations of a family - shared in the moment of birth. I look at her, and wonder what her life will bring. I practice using her name. This is a new name; a new person who I will treasure and pray for, for the rest of my days. I look at her features; the colour of her hair, the exquisite tone of her skin, the wonderfully made body. I observe the deep bond that is apparent in her mother, her father, and her 'big' brother; instinctive and intentional behaviours that protect the new child within a family unit. I have so much to be thankful for.
Yet even as I am awash in the joy and newness of new birth, I know there are times when even our best is insufficient. Times when a baby cries with tummy ache, or when a mother is overwhelmed with tiredness. Times when the needs of other children must be attended to. Times when we seek medical expertise for health problems that can sap us of energy. Times when our best is simply not good enough.
An abiding lesson that I have learnt from my contact over the years with newly born babies; my own children, the children of my friends and clients, and my grand-children, is the picture of the baby's craving for mother's milk. This analogy was drawn by Peter: "Like newborn infants, long for the pure, spiritual milk, so that by it you may grow." (1Peter 2:2)
In the same way as the newborn infant craves her mother's milk, and cannot be satisfied without it, the skill of the midwife is to work in harmony with this primal natural process.
Friday, March 22, 2013
strength
Following on from the previous post about submission to the spontaneous natural processes of birth, it may appear that I am fence-sitting to now write about strength.
Yet in normal childbirth, strength is the other side of the submission/surrender coin. There is probably no more emotionally challenging, physically demanding event that ordinary women face in life than the act of giving birth and nurturing a baby.
Readers who are mothers may recall the evenings, just prior to the births of your babies, when you have doubted your strength for the task ahead. When you have gone to bed hoping the baby doesn't need to be born tonight: "I just don't have the strength!"
(Your midwife might also experience that!)
Or, in labour, when you experience that overwhelming feeling of weariness. "How will I have the energy to keep going?"
(Your midwife might recognise that as progress, moving into an altered state of consciousness, when your thinking mind is suppressed, and the more instinctive, hormonally driven activities of your body can be freed up.)
Readers who know the ancient Biblical stories may remember Gideon, who was told by an angel that he had been chosen by God for the (rather daunting) task, to "deliver Israel from the hand of Midian" (Judges 6:14). Gideon argued that he was not suited for the task, that he came from the weakest clan in Israel, that his family were inconsequential, that he was the least significant person in his family ... . In response to Gideon's obfuscation, God's angel said "Go in this might of yours and deliver Israel." The power to achieve was there, even though Gideon continued to duck and dodge and try to avoid the job.
The strength to give birth is a deep inner strength that resides in a woman. Not in her logical, calculating mind. Not in her organised, planned day. But it's within her body, wonderfully made. And that strength can only be realised when we (the woman and the midwife) submit to the natural physiological processes, and refrain from interrupting these processes without a valid reason.
Yet in normal childbirth, strength is the other side of the submission/surrender coin. There is probably no more emotionally challenging, physically demanding event that ordinary women face in life than the act of giving birth and nurturing a baby.
Readers who are mothers may recall the evenings, just prior to the births of your babies, when you have doubted your strength for the task ahead. When you have gone to bed hoping the baby doesn't need to be born tonight: "I just don't have the strength!"
(Your midwife might also experience that!)
Or, in labour, when you experience that overwhelming feeling of weariness. "How will I have the energy to keep going?"
(Your midwife might recognise that as progress, moving into an altered state of consciousness, when your thinking mind is suppressed, and the more instinctive, hormonally driven activities of your body can be freed up.)
Readers who know the ancient Biblical stories may remember Gideon, who was told by an angel that he had been chosen by God for the (rather daunting) task, to "deliver Israel from the hand of Midian" (Judges 6:14). Gideon argued that he was not suited for the task, that he came from the weakest clan in Israel, that his family were inconsequential, that he was the least significant person in his family ... . In response to Gideon's obfuscation, God's angel said "Go in this might of yours and deliver Israel." The power to achieve was there, even though Gideon continued to duck and dodge and try to avoid the job.
The strength to give birth is a deep inner strength that resides in a woman. Not in her logical, calculating mind. Not in her organised, planned day. But it's within her body, wonderfully made. And that strength can only be realised when we (the woman and the midwife) submit to the natural physiological processes, and refrain from interrupting these processes without a valid reason.
Sunday, March 10, 2013
Submitting to the spontaneous
![]() |
| learning to breastfeed at an early age |
Today I am thinking especially of the lovely young mother in my care, who is waiting for spontaneous onset of labour (and all that follows).
I am also thinking about the young midwife whom I am mentoring, and who hopes to attend the birth with me. The work commitments that she has, together with other unpredictable factors, mean that each birth, each mother-baby consultation, needs to be negotiated in real time.
We are experiencing hot, dry weather, with hot nights in Melbourne at the moment. Energy is depleted as everyone goes about their tasks a little slower than usual. Perhaps this baby is waiting for a cool change?
The challenge of waiting for spontaneous onset of labour, and working in harmony with natural physiological processes demands submission from the midwife as well as the woman. Waiting and watching. It's a discipline, in which the midwife supports and watches, and in which the woman makes preparation, nesting and waiting.
Submission to the natural order, as well as to social expectations, happens moment by moment in life. Couples submit to each other, knowing that together they can achieve more than the sum of two lives. We submit to the road rules, not because we enjoy driving slowly, but because that's the way we can reduce the risk of collision and harm in built up areas. Parents submit to the needs of their young children, reorganising meal times, sleep times, ensuring healthy eating, and lots more to achieve harmony.
Submission will, at times, include an element of frustration. We all like to plan our days, We all value knowing what we need to do, and when we need to do it.
A midwife is unusual in that she has an imperative to accept unpredictability, and submit her own will to the greater forces that are at work in childbirth. A person cannot be an authentic midwife if, for whatever reason, they want to work 9-5, Monday - Friday. In recent decades the progressive medicalisation of birth has led to increasing rates of induction of labour, business hours maternity services, elective caesarean births, and the like. Medical management of the birthing process is the opposite of spontaneous birthing. Managed birthing sets up processes that use the staff and facilities of a hospital in the most productive way. Managed birthing tells midwives they don't need to submit to these unpredictable, wasteful, hormonally driven processes.
Yet it is the hormonal environment of spontaneous birth that sets a woman up for the next demanding steps in her journey: nurture, bonding, mothering. Without respect for these finely tuned processes, mothers can feel as though they are being processed in a factory. Without submission to and engagement with the natural processes. midwives become technicians who manage machines and who maintain the records for their employers.
Thankyou for your comments.
Monday, March 04, 2013
the second child
![]() | ||
| sister love |
The epiphany I had experienced in the sudden realisation of a new and deep loving for my first child contrasts strongly with the ease of spontaneous expansion of my capacity to love my second child, and each subsequent child, individually and without reserve.
I have observed the 'second child' phenomenon many times, and talked with mothers about it. As the months of the second pregnancy proceed there is often a niggling feeling of fear, that this wonderful mother-love that has been learned in the presence of the first, may in some way be threatened or diluted by the entry of the second into the home. Whether this fear is articulated, or merely pondered, it's often there.
And the answer arrives with the transition of baby#2 from womb to arms. How could I ever have doubted?
I am a second child. I experienced first hand the realities of being second. Parents who had done the hard yards, learning how to nourish, nurture, live with and teach a little person who is initially totally self-centred, how to think of others. Parents for whom the routines of parenting are much easier the second time round. And, the second child is never bored: the older sibling is on hand, so capable, giving the younger a model to aspire towards.
![]() |
| My mother, Ella White, holding baby Rebecca, our second child |
When my second child was born I spent a long time just looking at her. She was wonderfully different from her sister. Her darker complexion followed my features, while her sister was very fair. My mother had come the long flight from Brisbane, Queensland, to Haslett, Michigan, and she nurtured me so that I was free to nurture my children. She prepared simple meals that nourished my heart as well as my body. She encouraged and supported her son-in-law. Together we welcomed the second child into our home, and into our hearts, that had mysteriously enlarged to multiply the love that was available for our children.
I wonder if any of my readers have noticed the 'second child' phenomenon?
![]() |
| ps - Perhaps I handled my second child with greater confidence than the first? |
Saturday, February 23, 2013
working in harmony with great natural processes
| back-yard bounty |
The natural processes I am referring to include the wind and rain and sun; the soil; and the little group of brown-feathered cleaners (otherwise known as chooks) who maintain a weed-free and regularly fertilised soil wherever they go, but who are quite indiscriminate about what they scratch up and eat.
I work in harmony with these natural processes by choosing places that are exposed to enough sunshine, by watering when there is not enough rain, by adding natural fertilisers and root growth promoters to the soil, and by putting up fences to keep the hens away from plants that they would otherwise destroy. Some of these measures are even 'interventions', to use language familiar to midwifery. The end result is a healthy, bountiful harvest.
| Two rosellas in a peach tree |
We haven't always had good outcomes. When young plants are not watered, or supported, or given adequate nourishment, or protected from snails, or ...
Sometimes the fruit trees blossom during a rainy spell, and there aren't many bees to do the work of pollination, so not many fruit develop.
The other great natural (even back-yard) process that I seek to work in harmony with, and to intervene carefully into if and when appropriate, is (of course) childbearing.
It's not enough to simply declare my trust in natural birth; to admire the function of the woman's body; the integration of physical, emotional and hormonal energies that work so marvelously most of the time.
I, the midwife, function in a similar way to the gardener. I must understand and respect all the forces, internal and external, that are at play. I must take measures that will prevent harm from illness (eg pests) or poor nutrition (eg by rotating plants to different garden beds), or physical forces (eg the chookies).
A midwife colleague challenged me recently when I described a situation when I accompanied a woman in labour to hospital. After what I considered to be a reasonable period of time had passed, during which the physical progress of the baby into the birth canal was minimal, the woman agreed to a caesarean birth. I agreed with this decision.
My colleague questioned me sincerely: was I not concerned that the act of going (from home) to hospital could have interfered sufficiently with the labour to CAUSE the obstruction of progress? Could this woman have given birth 'naturally' if her physiology had not been interfered with?
My answer: No.
I know this because I was there. This woman's body did all it could, under the natural physiological processes and rules, and it was time to move to Plan B.
The sobering thought, that we must not forget, is that even wonderful natural processes can lead to death and mayhem. Recognising the points at which timely, and relatively small interventions, such as health promotion through improving diet and activity in pregnancy, or major interventions, such as the need for a caesarean birth, is the work of the midwife. Just as the back-yard bounty is evidence of many months of careful work, the healthy newborn baby, at the breast of the strong and healthy woman, is evidence of a woman's strength and care of herself and her baby, as well as appropriate maternity care.
Thursday, February 21, 2013
Saturday, February 16, 2013
Informed or mistaken?
Informed choiceIn my world the adjective 'informed' is often used in an attempt to declare that the person who is making the 'informed' choice/decision/refusal/whatever is intelligent, and has carefully considered options. My question is, often, who's kidding whom?
Informed decision
Informed refusal
...
A woman who wants to make an informed choice about who provides her care, and other aspects of the model of care, can only choose from what is available to her.
A woman who wants to make an informed decision, particularly about an aspect of natural, physiological birth, may say she does not want to be treated as the next number on the production line. She does not want standard care, whatever that is. She wants to be treated as an individual.
A woman who wants to make an informed refusal of, for example, pre-labour caesarean surgery for a baby presenting breech, can find herself up against a system that does not support or understand her intentions.
In the often complex and demanding journey that a woman takes in giving birth to and nurturing her baby, the information available can be only marginally relevant to the individual situation: the choices and decisions can appear as shades of grey, rather than good and bad. The constant juggling of the interests of the woman and her child, within the multiple contexts of a marriage, a family, a maternity service, and a community, can change the options for decisions in a moment. In fact, a woman who considers herself well informed, and who is intentional about proceeding with an unmedicated physiological birth, has very little choice when some person with authority says "We need to get your baby delivered now." A woman in labour who is confronted with even the suggestion that her baby's condition may be compromised, without whatever intervention is being offered, can suddenly find herself submitting to something that she would otherwise have avoided.
Health care, and especially maternity care, has changed in recent decades, from a "doctor-knows-best"-no-discussion model, with a hierarchical knowledge-based framework, to a system that attempts to include and respect the wishes and values of the patient/client. This is, I believe, to be encouraged in principle. But, in practice, I am often frustrated at the absence of an appropriate conversation about decisions or choices that need to be made.
At present the Melbourne Coroner's office is inquiring into the circumstances around the death of a baby whose mother intended to give birth at home. Newspaper reports of this inquiry highlight the fact that the mother had refused caesarean surgery a few days before she came into labour. In a news paper report of the proceedings, a medical specialist is reported to have said that:
the "inadequate, incomplete and at times misleading information" available, particularly on the internet, made it difficult for women to make an informed decision about their birth plans.There is little doubt from the reports that the mother believed she had made informed decisions. Yet, in the tragedy of loss of the life of a baby, it's easy to argue that there were seriously mistaken decisions that led to the events of that day.
Women who have had previous caesarean birth(s) may make choices and decisions about their carers, and their planned place of birth, early in their pregnancies. By way of contrast, women who find that their baby is presenting breech as they approach Term are suddenly confronted with a bewildering array of decisions. As they obtain information they become aware that there is no right way (eg elective caesarean) and wrong way. There is increased risk in breech birth, regardless of the actual method of birth. At each decision point, they can feel exposed and uninformed, even misled - but decisions must be made and there is no turning back. Each decision places the participants in a new context, which may lead to more decision-making.
A woman who had planned to give birth naturally in a hospital birth centre found that her baby was frank breech a couple of days after her due date. The special set of decision points that she encountered after the breech diagnosis were:
- attempt external cephalic version (ECV): the decision was made on Saturday that this baby was not suitable for ECV, and the mother was informed that she would be booked for a Caesarean on Monday.
- spontaneous onset of labour: Mother laboured at home Sunday night, and called her midwife for support around midnight.
- progress in labour: After several hours of established labour, the mother's cervix was dilated 6-7cm, and the presenting part was high. The decision was made to go to hospital. Labour continued strongly. The obstetrics registrar at the hospital agreed that progress was good, but advised a caesarean birth. The mother declined, and stated that she was intending to give birth vaginally. All maternal and fetal observations were within normal range.
- review of progress in labour: After several more hours of labour, full dilation of the cervix was confirmed, but no progress of the presenting part. Once again the mother was advised that she needed caesarean surgery, and this time she agreed. Her baby was born in good condition, and the hospital staff facilitated early skin to skin contact and breastfeeding in the recovery area of the OT.
In discussion a week after the birth, this woman commented to her midwife, "You know, it's a totally different outcome, having a caesarean birth after labour, knowing that I couldn't do any more myself, than if I had agreed to it the first or second time I was told I needed it."
The midwife agreed. The decision making process included an ongoing review of the progress of mother and baby through uncharted terrain. The decisions were made on the best information available. There was ultimately only one *choice* - for the woman to do it herself, or not. This is the only informed birth plan a woman can make, and follow through with.
related posts:
decision making for breech
breech vaginal birth
messages about breech births
Saturday, February 09, 2013
BIRTH STORY
The Day You Came
Wanda Ruby Bean
From a distance the sound of familiar footsteps enter, softly
resonating the hallway boards. That long cool passage welcomes and grounds the
energy of arrival, and those footsteps always speak to me of strength,
confidence and calmness. They are slow, they are regular, and they belong, each
time they place themselves down, yet there is a lightness to them that contains
their energy, allowing them to change their course. These are the footsteps of
my father. They are the rhythm.
There is a second set of footsteps proceeding, which skate
and dance on the surface. They have the same base confidence whilst infusing a
melody of willingness, playfulness and excitement, the footsteps of my mother.
As the footsteps reach the end of the passage, time and
space briefly pause. The early afternoon sun has just begun to creep through
the wooden blinds and open door, filling the room with the blissful warmth and
breeze of a perfect day. From over backyard fences and beyond, a relaxed inhabited
neighbourhood enters the room, joining us in building the sense of this
gathering and impending celebration.
We are all here now, and it is soon to be that you will join
us.
Joy is here – she kneels by the pool quietly guiding me to allow
you to work your way down, and to allow my body to open by degrees until your
head can come through. She squeezes a cramp from my thigh. I bury my face into the
crook of her arm. Our eyes meet and I tell her ‘I’m glad you’re here’.
She gives me the practical confidence at this stage that I
need to enjoy this moment and to trust the forces and the will of my body and
yours.
Hamish is here – he has been on the edges, balancing between
active support and giving me space. He has prepared the room in the final hours
to absolute, in timing, function and style, invited the guests, thought about
lunch, and even got the bins out in time for collection. And as only Hamish
could, has peppered his day with a set of slightly mad but comical dramas.
He is beside me at the pools edge. He even offers up his
flesh for my bite, a running joke we have had. I appreciate it but decline,
briefly gnawing on the pool instead. He holds me, and I tell him ‘Beano is coming’. We exchange a look of
excitement and bemusement, the humour we share about this realisation that has
never yet really sunk in. I don’t need physical or emotional support from him,
I need to include him in this moment and feel the union that we are in order to
bring you into our world together.
Mum is here – she peeps shyly over to me holding a face and
breath of thrill, anticipation and quietness. The same energy I recognise at
times that I have been witness to an animal birthing. ‘Hello’ and my wide eyes greet her in smile. I am relieved she has
made it in time, and relieved that this is the moment she has arrived. Before
long she slips easily under Joys instruction to prepare warm towels and other
things in preparation, as you are nearly here. The combination of gentle
mothering and practical assistant is the perfect and natural balance of how I
had wanted to share this journey of womanhood with her.
Dad is here – a welcome addition to the arrangements. He
primarily came to deliver mum and take Velouer out for a walk. As it turned out
Velouer is completely calm. It is so close to the time you will arrive th0at he
stays quietly in the background. I am happy he is here, and want to tell him.
Under my breath I invite him to stay. I don’t think anyone hears me but the
atmosphere as it is, is enough for him to feel welcome and comfortable to stay.
I feel an extra sense of love and significance that he does.
Velouer is here – my beautiful loyal dog. He has been with
me throughout. In the early hours of the day he lay beside me, calmly and
comfortably as I worked physically and vocally with the surges in my body. It
had been thought by others that he would be distressed by the energy of my
birthing. I knew that he would be fine, and I had wanted him here. We are part
of each other and we understand on an instinctual level. He gives me comfort by
just being, eyes to talk to, and an energy of calm. He gives me space but is
there, there to protect me as people arrive, and there to accept and welcome
the people as he knows them. He takes his place as he always does amongst the
people and space in the room. I tell him ‘good
boy’.
I am here – I have always been here with you, and until now
had you all to myself… although you have kept yourself well as a little
mystery, a quiet enigma.
In the hours of this day I have re-found the essential core
connection to my body, brought my mind in and allowed and trusted the forces,
the choices and the beings that surround me now.
Just one little wild card is you. As my body works in the
final stages to release and expel you I embody a physical memory of a young
goat birthing her first kid. She lays in the hay calmly allowing the process, as
the head finally pops out beyond return, a brief flash of shock and then
realisation of what this labour is all for comes across her face. Then the long
glorious quiver as your body swims from me and comes up to land in the air, our
bodies skin to skin.
You have arrived – a tiny little stranger person. Taking
your first breaths with sleepy eyes blinking quietly, with little wrinkled
hands you gently play and clutch at the air. You take a shy little peek up to
me. I hold you to my belly and paddle the warm water over your body with my
hand, letting us the time to readjust and take it in.
Everyone is having their own special moments with you around
us. Like a conglomerate of prismatic bubbles floating gently in the earthly sun
filled room.
Wanda Ruby Bean - we love you to pieces already.
Frances Martin
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
.jpg)






